Recommended Characters

All of the Recommended Characters in Order of Appearance
(incomplete) 

Episode 11
 * 1) Bomby -by jaysillyboy

Episode 12

 * 1) Nonexisty -by MoragaSam
 * 2) Paper -by mycarzypets
 * 3) Sheet of Paper -by Qynze
 * 4) Lightbulb -by liamt44
 * 5) Triangle -by simondomino
 * 6) Marshmallow -by simondomino
 * 7) Basketball -by BlockyCuzco
 * 8) Dollar -by simondomino
 * 9) Gumball -by simondomino (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 10) Quarter -by BlockyCuzco
 * 11) Domino -by simondomino
 * 12) Candle -by AlphaZaver
 * 13) Seashell -by AlphaZaver
 * 14) Football -by alexlion05
 * 15) Purple Marker -by AlphaZaver
 * 16) Orange Marker -by alexlion05

Episode 13

 * 1) Remote -by punx193
 * 2) Batteries -by jacknjellify
 * 3) American Flag -by alexlion05
 * 4) Bottle -by VRTBV
 * 5) Scissors -by Ben1178
 * 6) Snowflake -by alexlion05
 * 7) TNT -by simondimono
 * 8) Rose -by firemoss1
 * 9) Treeyee -by frezblade
 * 10) Dice [sic] -by simondomino
 * 11) Fork -by simondomino
 * 12) Football -by spongron
 * 13) Balloony -by simondomino & Ben1178
 * 14) Candy -by PunkPrincessMusic
 * 15) Wandy-by geriolah7
 * 16) Ball -by jaysillyboy
 * 17) Knife -by Allie2489
 * 18) Crayon -by alexlion05
 * 19) Pencil Grip -by Brom316
 * 20) Phone -by simondomino
 * 21) Peanut Butter -by simondomino
 * 22) Peanut -by yummysimon4
 * 23) Nutcracker -by yummysimon4
 * 24) Cloudy -by VRTBV

Episode 14

 * 1) Bally -by Spongebobvideopants
 * 2) Marble -by simondomino
 * 3) Spoon -by simondomino
 * 4) Rubiny -by TheStormMage
 * 5) Tin -by Flame904Animations
 * 6) Sticker -by hasbro33
 * 7) Bracelet -by hasbro33
 * 8) Bell -by amphiprionic
 * 9) Penguiny -by frezblade
 * 10) Clippy -by VRTBV
 * 11) Cardboard -by VRTBV
 * 12) Grassy -by spakwee
 * 13) Tombstone -by TGOTY900
 * 14) Sharpener -by liamt44
 * 15) Lava Lamp -by simondomino
 * 16) Soda -by simondomino
 * 17) Frosting -by simondomino
 * 18) Jelly -by simondomino
 * 19) Crane -by desmundhume
 * 20) Brick -by TDIFAN99 (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 21) Cuppy -by worldsubways13
 * 22) Disc -by worldsubways13
 * 23) Game Controller -by worldsubways13
 * 24) Pillow -by desmundhume
 * 25) Masky -by RedPansClubPenguin
 * 26) TV -by RedPansClubPenguin
 * 27) Speaky -by RedPansClubPenguin
 * 28) Radio -by RedPansClubPenguin
 * 29) WiiMote -by PestramiShowALT
 * 30) Cherry -by PestramiShowALT
 * 31) Cup -by jaysillyboy
 * 32) DVD -by GoofTheCar61
 * 33) Gummy -by DeWayneWalker
 * 34) Paintbrush -by simondomino
 * 35) Flashlight -by simondomino
 * 36) Computer -by bigbookid92 (has another version recommended by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 37) Comby -by simondomino
 * 38) Slipper -by georgiaabigail2000
 * 39) Marker -by georgiaabigail2000 (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 40) TV -by georgiaabigail2000
 * 41) Receipt -by Randomness114
 * 42) Book -by MrGeorge2220
 * 43) Candycane -by Carraid73
 * 44) Poop -by EnchantiCam
 * 45) Card -by leonid123ism
 * 46) Bushy -by TeamToothless1
 * 47) Starfish -by simondomino
 * 48) Teddy Bear -by PunkPrincessMusic
 * 49) 3D Glasses -by PunkPrincessMusic
 * 50) Yoyo -by PunkPrincessMusic
 * 51) 1st Clock -by Xxangelwings1234xX
 * 52) 2nd Clock -by losmmorpg
 * 53) Cereal -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 54) Baggy -by yummysimon4
 * 55) Watch -by losmmorpg
 * 56) Drum Stick -by simondomino
 * 57) Pack of Crayons -by Brom316
 * 58) Glue Stick -by simondomino
 * 59) Robot -by Clone4848
 * 60) Celly -by maliksanford
 * 61) Pie Man -by FlykydFly
 * 62) Marshmally -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 63) Trombone -by glridgel7
 * 64) Colored Pencil -by glridgel7
 * 65) Banana -by englishcreamcakes
 * 66) Gumball -by englishcreamcakes
 * 67) Marshmallow -by lavaboyoh
 * 68) Hole in the Wall -by alexlion05
 * 69) Puddle -by englishcreamcakes
 * 70) Splashy -by englishcreamcakes
 * 71) Hanger -by alexlion05
 * 72) Basketball -by alexlion05
 * 73) Dynamite -by englishcreamcakes
 * 74) Suitcase -by alexlion05
 * 75) Car -by alexlion05
 * 76) Sword -by alexlion05
 * 77) taco guy -by MyMarioMan101
 * 78) Frisbee -by alexlion05
 * 79) Firey Jr. -by alexlion05
 * 80) 777 -by JACKIEMON1
 * 81) Mechanical Pencil -by AwesomeMudkipKing
 * 82) Snowman -by simondomino
 * 83) Lighter -by CPFAN2000
 * 84) Lily -by AxleEgo
 * 85) Boxy -by jaysillyboy
 * 86) Eggy -by kiks2506
 * 87) Tele -by 1191Bman
 * 88) Wolf Puppet -by spongron
 * 89) Mechanical Flower -by tomatid1
 * 90) Computer -by megacooltommydee
 * 91) Chocolate Bar -by MrGeorge2220
 * 92) Nickel -by DuncanEpic
 * 93) Soccer Ball -by simondomino
 * 94) Midget Apple -by flamer9111
 * 95) Branchy -by MegaFeRex
 * 96) DS -by flamer9111

The large crowd at Cake at Stake

 * 1) Moon -by jaysillyboy
 * 2) Sun -by jaysillyboy
 * 3) Doom -by dorthelthree
 * 4) Lollipop -by jmarston123
 * 5) Bombey -by jmarston123
 * 6) Pinball -by Explosion772
 * 7) Snappy -by justincasekazoo
 * 8) Mango -by hasbro33
 * 9) Basketball -by kookyguy55 (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 10) Computer Chip -by VRTBV
 * 11) Dragon -by poppeild
 * 12) Foot -by TDIfan9991
 * 13) Hand -by TDIfan9991
 * 14) Pickle -by TDIfan9991
 * 15) Lollipop -by pinkbelossom
 * 16) Pillow -by hasbro33
 * 17) Gold Fish -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 18) 8-Ball -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 19) Earring -by TeamToothless1
 * 20) Blueberry -by BlockyCuzco
 * 21) Shoe -by TDIfan9991
 * 22) Cheesy -by totaldrama23
 * 23) Eggy -by SHARNNICE
 * 24) Envelope -by BlockyCuzco
 * 25) Blanket -by tyboy618
 * 26) Pillow -by tyboy618
 * 27) VCR -by hasbro33
 * 28) DVD -by hasbro33
 * 29) Pyramid -by paulstelian97
 * 30) Tent -by jmarston123
 * 31) Daisy -by imhere13231
 * 32) Picture -by glridgel7
 * 33) Swifty -by Veer716
 * 34) Calcy -by Theunknown9977
 * 35) Popcorn -by TDAWorld
 * 36) Peanut Butter Cup -by DuncanEpic
 * 37) Sword -by hasbro33
 * 38) George the Marshmallow -by bettinamusic8
 * 39) Knife -by Ziggyfan325
 * 40) Waffle 1 -by frezblade
 * 41) Waffle 2 -by tdifan11111
 * 42) Piey -by frezblade
 * 43) Crunch Pebble -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 44) Vanilla Strawberry -by pinkbelossom
 * 45) Cupcake -by pinkbelossom
 * 46) Rubik's Cube -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 47) Blueberry Pie -by Spongebobvideopants
 * 48) Bottle -by jaysillyboy
 * 49) Lamp -by BrawlRocks1290
 * 50) Pie -by nheonhoc
 * 51) Pancake -by pinkbelossom
 * 52) Maple Syrup Pancake -by pinkbelossom
 * 53) Cereal -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 54) China -by englishcreamcakes
 * 55) Locker -by englishcreamcakes
 * 56) David -by TDICaitlincookegroup
 * 57) Dora -by JACKIEMON1
 * 58) Rick Roll -by JACKIEMON1
 * 59) Ash -by JACKIEMON1
 * 60) Brock -by JACKIEMON1
 * 61) Asparagy -by Nesla13luv
 * 62) Box -by BrawlRocks1290
 * 63) Coral -by Spongebobvideopants
 * 64) Screwdriver -by Carraid73
 * 65) Ice Cream -by simondomino
 * 66) Croissant -by alexrox0005
 * 67) Dart -by Ziggyfan325
 * 68) Boom -by njjoe9797
 * 69) Radio -by glridgel7
 * 70) Ice Cream Sandwich -by simondomino
 * 71) Délo the Chocolate Bar -by EpicMason
 * 72) Lego Man -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 73) Lego Brick -by lavaboyoh
 * 74) Kick Ball -by englishcreamcakes
 * 75) Apple -by englishcreamcakes
 * 76) Tomato -by englishcreamcakes
 * 77) Snow Globe -by englishcreamcakes
 * 78) Clones -by Clone4848
 * 79) Smencil -by yummysimon4
 * 80) Traffic Cone -by Vivapinata0407
 * 81) Marker -by alexlion05 (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 82) Hour Glass -by simondomino
 * 83) Yellow Teddy -by pinkbelossom
 * 84) Panda -by JACKIEMON1
 * 85) Wine Glass -by Zakary42
 * 86) Hammer -by englishcreamcakes
 * 87) Cherry -by englishcreamcakes
 * 88) Earth Globe -by englishcreamcakes
 * 89) Deoderant -by ZackTheEpic
 * 90) Rice Cake -by TheBombDigityShis
 * 91) Red Pen -by simondomino
 * 92) Lappy -by MrOrange890
 * 93) Book -by simondomino
 * 94) Mario Cap -by PestramiShowALT

The "cake" used

 * 1) Nickel -by BlockyCuzco

Contest

 * 1) Barf Bag -by desmundhume
 * 2) Taco -by TDIfan9991

During the puppets

 * 1) Blue Spongy -by simondomino

The large crowd at Cake at Stake

 * 1) Pencil Case -by pngos
 * 2) Paper Bag -by worldsubways13
 * 3) Socky -by fishhooksmilo100
 * 4) Game Boy -by MrZachgreat
 * 5) Cellphone -by maxbigtoe
 * 6) Lolly Pop -by xXandytraicyXx
 * 7) Bomsai -by pinkbelossom
 * 8) Saxophone -by MRNATE989
 * 9) French Fries -by misha1966
 * 10) Cake 1 -by jmarston123
 * 11) Cake 2 -by xXangelwings1234Xx
 * 12) Ropey -by TheLegobatman3609
 * 13) Epic Smiley
 * 14) Zombie
 * 15) Yoshi
 * 16) Bowling Ball
 * 17) Bowling Pin
 * 18) Kino
 * 19) PestramiShowALT
 * 20) Alex
 * 21) Colby
 * 22) Salesman
 * 23) Human
 * 24) Female Version
 * 25) Nickel
 * 26) Dictionary
 * 27) Iron
 * 28) Disco
 * 29) Rubber Duckie
 * 30) Lawn Mower
 * 31) Baby Coiny
 * 32) Nurse Lilly
 * 33) Ms. Speaker Thing
 * 34) Laddy
 * 35) Torso
 * 36) Paper
 * 37) Hattie
 * 38) Spammy
 * 39) Dumbbell
 * 40) Mayonnaise
 * 41) Cheeseburger
 * 42) Tack
 * 43) Naily
 * 44) Nailey
 * 45) Song
 * 46) Dance
 * 47) Car Engine
 * 48) Deep Fryer
 * 49) Bowling Ball (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 50) Bowling Ball
 * 51) Hilly
 * 52) Bottley
 * 53) Drink
 * 54) Blue Water Bottle
 * 55) Water Tap
 * 56) O (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 57) M (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 58) G (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 59) Mario
 * 60) Luigi
 * 61) Princess Peach
 * 62) Weegee
 * Key
 * 1) Bob-Omb
 * 2) TV
 * 3) Chilly
 * 4) Fridge (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 5) Heater
 * 6) Ball Card
 * 7) Egg
 * 8) Stapler
 * 9) Windows live
 * 10) Door
 * 11) Backpack
 * 12) Treasure Map
 * 13) Army
 * 14) Boulder
 * 15) Mr. Imagination
 * 16) Robot Rocky
 * 17) Robot Flower
 * 18) Wii Game Case
 * 19) Pink Tennis Ball
 * 20) Bubble Blower (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 21) Magnet Man
 * Key
 * 1) Bomby (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 2) Pencil Clone
 * 3) Sharpie
 * 4) Blue Match
 * 5) Tamago
 * 6) Tornado
 * 7) Sushi
 * 8) YouTube Logo
 * 9) Magic Carpet
 * 10) Cheese
 * 11) Bacon
 * 12) Orange
 * 13) Book
 * 14) Wine Glass
 * Zip
 * 1) Saturn (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 2) Shirt
 * 3) Football (in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 4) TV
 * 5) Cuppy
 * 6) Fanny
 * 7) Keyboard
 * 8) Peacy

The "cake" used

 * 1) Blueberry Pie -by Spongebobvideopants, frezblade & nheonhoc

Objects for the competition

 * 1) Blocky and Pencil's Bowling Ball
 * 2) Bowling Pin
 * 3) Bubble's Bowling Ball
 * 4) Leafy and possibly Firey's Bowling Ball

Episode 17
(see Recommended Characters/Episode 17)

The Crowd at Cake at Stake

 * Sky
 * 1) Snowman
 * TNT
 * 1) Companion Cube
 * 2) Henrique
 * 3) Wandy
 * 4) Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
 * 5) Lopez
 * 6) WALL-E
 * 7) Couch
 * 8) Blue Pencil
 * 9) Orange Eraser
 * 10) Youdrop
 * 11) Elimination Contestants (all the contestants meshed together)
 * 12) Bracelety
 * 13) Disky
 * 14) Cacsteel
 * 15) Bread
 * 16) Giant D
 * 17) Painty
 * 18) Battery
 * Wii
 * 1) Ball (by the First Pencil Voter)
 * 2) Popcorn
 * PSP
 * 1) Spider Man
 * 2) Poop
 * 3) Izzy
 * 4) Jessalyn
 * 5) DS Game
 * 6) PennMap (by the First Pencil Voter's friend)
 * 7) Juice Box
 * Boo
 * 1) Baseball
 * 2) Question Mark
 * 3) Swordy
 * 4) Flamed Stove
 * 5) Diamond (also in one of the First Pencil Voter's shows)
 * 6) Balloony (by the First Pencil Voter but excluded due to one recommended character per recommender)

The contraption used as Leafy wins the tiebreaker

 * 1) Scissors
 * 2) Laddy
 * 3) Hammer
 * 4) Ropey

The "cake" used when David joins

 * 1) Yellow Tomato

Episode 19
(see Recommended Characters/Episode 19)

Episode 20
(see Recommended Characters/Episode 20)

Episode 21
(see Recommended Characters/Episode 21)

===Episode 24 (see Recommended Characters/Episode 24)

BFDIA 6


 * car
 * 1) evil teardrop
 * 2) teardrop anger
 * 3) woody love
 * 4) cake at stake
 * 5) baseball
 * 6) putinuia
 * 7) grabouillion
 * 8) evil firey speaker box
 * 9) evil pin
 * 10) firey and puffball is love
 * 11) tennis ball and golf ball is love