List of edible items and characters

This is a comprehensive list of all edibles in Battle For Dream Island

Edible characters

 * Donut
 * Fries (fry tasted by Book, eaten by Gelatin)
 * Gelatin
 * The Cheese Orb**

IDFB
There are also edible Recommended Characters who appear very briefly.
 * Eggy
 * Taco
 * Pie**
 * Cake
 * Lollipop

** character was used as a Cake for Cake at Stake

Edible items

 * our gumball*
 * a hundred chocolate balls*
 * an egg
 * Bomby's banana*
 * Bomby's cake*
 * banana upon which someone slips
 * Pen's apple
 * loaves of bread*
 * Pencil's ice cream cone
 * Ondo Mino
 * Fries's fries
 * yoyleberries
 * donut u 2
 * Coiny's seeds
 * Pin's ooze*

Ingredients

 * rice
 * strawberries
 * flour
 * jars of unknown contents
 * unidentified pink goo
 * blueberries
 * yeast
 * sugar
 * inedible ingredients including:
 * cyanide
 * liquid cyanide
 * dirt
 * boogers
 * Rub-bing alco-hol
 * bugs
 * Bleach
 * Blood
 * VX
 * fertilizer
 * HCl
 * gunpowder
 * poison dart frogs
 * poison dart frogs bag
 * bubble solution
 * H₂SO₄
 * lava
 * marbles
 * Smallpox Virus
 * Botulinum Toxin
 * vomit
 * nails
 * Parathion
 * polonium 210
 * knives
 * empty ice cream cone
 * whipped cream
 * beef
 * beans
 * tortilla shells
 * lettuce
 * fish
 * eggs
 * tomatoes

Cakes from Sweet Tooth

 * Coiny's baked dirt cake
 * Tennis Ball's rice cake
 * Needle's superplanetary rice cake
 * Pin's Flower Cake
 * Golf Ball's dirty cake†
 * Firey's unidentified brown cake
 * Rocky's bowl of vomit and water
 * Leafy's giant strawberry cake
 * chunks sold to Pen, Eraser, Woody, Match, Pencil, and Bubble†
 * note: Tear Drop's and Snowball's cakes were not seen

Tacos from Vomitaco

 * Leafy's giant lettuce, beef, and tomato taco*
 * half sold to Pen*
 * Spongy's lettuce, fish, and tomato taco*
 * Tennis Ball's lettuce and tomato taco*
 * Firey's slightly burnt lettuce and tomato taco*

Cakes and Tacos from Hurtful!

 * Flower's dirt cake
 * Bubble's dirt cake
 * Leafy's dirt cake
 * Firey's non-dirt cake
 * Bubble's lettuce, fish, and tomato taco

Stews from Get Digging
*item was actually eaten
 * WOAH Bunch's mashed yoyleberries
 * Team No-Name's complicated stew

†item was definitely consumed by a speaker box

Cake at Stake cakes
full article: Cakes

Other Items that have been eaten

 * Rocky's vomit (by Coiny)
 * frisbees (by Spongy; tasted by Rocky and Firey)
 * small green sea monster (by gray sea monster)

Other Characters who have been eaten

 * Emergency Button (by Rocky)
 * Flower (by Fire Monster; tasted by Pin)
 * Firey (by Fire Monster)
 * Leafy (by gray sea monster)
 * Purple Face (by Yellow Face)
 * corner of Announcer (by Flower)
 * bugs (by Yellow Face)

Characters who pretended to get eaten

 * Blocky, Woody, Pin, Needle, Teardrop, Golf Ball, Coiny, Snowball, Match, Eraser, Pen, Tennis Ball, Pencil, Rocky, and Spongy (by the bugs)
 * Firey (by the bugs)

Other Items or Characters who have been tasted but not eaten

 * Blocky (by small orange fish)
 * Pencil (by green sea monster)
 * Nonexisty (by Firey)
 * Ice Cube
 * (in Pencil's ice cream cone, by Bubble and Pencil)
 * (by Ice Cube)
 * spike ball (by Rocky)
 * Book (by Fries)