In IDFB, Coiny is currently free due to not being eliminated before "Intruder Alert".
In Battle for BFDI, Coiny competed on The Losers! until the split in "The Escape from Four" where he left the show to compete on Two's show.
In Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two, Coiny competed on Team8s until "Outbreak at Stake" where he was eliminated with 4,870 votes, however he wasn't eliminated immediately due to getting zombified. He originally placed 30th overall. However, due to Pencil and Liy joining in “Category One”, he ended up placing 32nd overall.
What team did Coiny compete on in Battle for Dream Island?
In Battle for Dream Island Again, Coiny joins Donut's team. By season 4, Coiny and his former rival, Firey, are on the same team, which balances new and returning members until Leafy's return.
Provided by: Fandom
Why was Coiny eliminated in 'A Leg Up in the Race' episode?
In the 'A Leg Up in the Race' episode, Coiny's elimination resulted from garnering the highest number of votes during the Cake at Stake. This was largely influenced by his persistent feud with another contestant, Firey. Coiny's elimination was marked by a record 40 votes, the most any contestant had accumulated at that point.
Provided by: Fandom
What is the relationship between Coiny and Pin in BFDI?
In BFDI, Coiny and Pin have a strong bond. They've experienced ups and downs, including periods of discord. Pin, known for her team spirit and motivation, often supports Coiny. Despite her occasional hesitation in confronting tasks, their friendship is characterized by mutual encouragement and high-fives.
Provided by: Fandom
What is the significance of 'bread coiny' in the series?
The term 'bread coiny' originates from an episode where Coiny participates in a competition, aiming to fill his basket with bread loaves. However, he ends up drowning in the bread, a situation enjoyed by his adversary, Firey. In a different episode, Coiny proposes a strategy to ensnare a character named Two using his bread. These instances underline Coiny's competitive nature and strategic approach.
Provided by: Fandom
How does Coiny's role evolve in Battle for Dream Island Again?
Coiny's role in Battle for Dream Island Again sees him chasing Leafy into the Evil Canyon and joining BFDIA. He aligns with Donut on his team and persuades Pin to switch sides. Despite losing a tug-of-war contest, Coiny shows unexpected unity with Firey over Flower's destructive actions. Coiny's competitive nature is also highlighted when he bets he can outperform Pin in a challenge.
Provided by: Fandom
Appearance[]
Coiny is a metal coin that, while not a penny,[3] is often referred to as such (stated by Eraser in "Sweet Tooth"). His body is a bright copper color. Between BFDI and BFDIA, his edges were rounded to make him a perfect circle.
Changes[]
Pre-debut
Coiny's outlines are an orange-ish yellow.
Coiny's outlines are loosely drawn and vary in thickness.
Although Coiny is nice sometimes, he is relatively rude most of the time. In addition, he occasionally has conflicts with others. The most notable of which is with Firey. During the first season, he had an intense hatred toward him when the two frequently slapped each other in episodes. This was because Coiny forgot about Firey's poison, water.
Coiny has also shown an ability of persuasion and charisma. He generally tries to give speeches toward the other contestants on several accounts throughout the series. He was even able to convince Firey to let him into Dream Island.
Coiny now has many more or less rude and abrasive moments than before with some of the contestants who aren't his friends, such as Teardrop, Bomby, and Spongy. He is also more of a leader and a strategist coming up with ideas to help his team and Pin. For example, he convinced her to switch teams and used his teammates' abilities to benefit them in certain challenges. Initially, Coiny is somewhat callous and unfriendly—in "No More Snow!", he is unconcerned by the prospect of Spongy, Needle, and even Pin being dead forever since it increases his chances of winning. He also forces several contestants to switch to his team by threatening them.
However, as the season progresses, Coiny matures and mellows out. In the latter half, he becomes a voice of reason for the more aggressive Pin, frequently checking on her well-being and trying to calm her down when she's upset, like when she’s frustrated at Ruby stealing her song in "PointyPointyPointy ♫". Additionally, in the same episode, Coiny expresses frustration when Pin is the target of jokes and takes action to support her, such as spinning the prize wheel on her behalf to ensure she receives a favorable outcome. This emphasizes Coiny's loyalty and protective nature, especially towards Pin. He works closely with her to complete the challenges, and his willingness to assist in fixing her mech suit shows his commitment to teamwork.
Coiny is shown to be somewhat childish and energetic. This is shown in "Welcome Back," where he yells that the grotatoes will taste delicious and tries to eat them when they've barely began growing. He also hypes up the wall teleporter calling it his "favorite thing in the whole world" despite not knowing what it is. Finally, in the stinger ending of the episode, he gleefully takes "deep-fried breaths" with boiling frying oil, much to Fries' and Leafy's terror.
Coiny is nicer and also much more thoughtful. Some examples of this are shown when he comforts Pin in "Four Goes Too Far" and offers Marker some dirt cake in "This Episode Is About Basketball". He also seems to have grown closer to Firey over this time.
Coiny showcases his ability to think creatively and utilize the strengths of his teammates to achieve the team's goal, such as in "You Know Those Buttons Don't Do Anything, Right?" when Coiny uses Pin to climb the building. This also influences the strategy of the other team members, indicating that Coiny's actions can have a broader impact on the team.
He also appears to be strongly attached to how things used to be, particularly regarding his relationship with Pin during their time in BFDIA. In "The Worst Day of Black Hole's Life," when Pin expresses discomfort with using glue in this challenge and shares her dislike for that season, it disrupts Coiny’s perception of their dynamic, leaving him confused and questioning this unexpected side of Pin, since he liked to win in BFDIA.
Abilities[]
Strengths[]
Heat resistance: Coiny is immune to lava thanks to his metallic body. This allows him to slap Firey without pain. He can also survive being melted as shown in "Well, Look Who It Is!" when travelling through the Earth.
Flatness: Being a coin, Coiny can be flat enough to go through a fence, just like in "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know".
Telepathy: In "Intruder Alert", Coiny appeared to intrude Pin's thoughts, agreeing that the team needed a better team leader. He was also able to communicate this back, much to Pin’s surprise. This ability is further utilized in "Insectophobe's Nightmare 4", when Pin communicates with him in a type of thought after losing her limbs, face and size. This also briefly occurs in "Well, Look Who It Is!".
Good Eyesight: In "Intruder Alert", when Firey Speaker Box sends Rocky to the Locker of Losers but it's closed, Coiny says 'That's not good... shouldn't he go in?' even though the Locker of Losers is miles and miles away.
Voice Switching: In “Taste The Sweetness”, when Barbecue Sauce thinks that he isn’t the Coiny he knows due to his voice being Needle’s voice, he creates a reaction that switches his and Needle’s voice back. There is no proof that Needle did anything because after the scene, Needle just realized that her voice switched so we know that Coiny was the one who made the reaction.
Money Explosion: If Nickel was too close to Coiny, not only a black vortex will appear in the middle of them, but also the vortex will blast coins and dollars up into the air. This happened in "The Long-lost Yoyle City", where Pin pushed Nickel into him, causing them to create a money-blasting portal.
Strong Stomach: In "Respect to the Wicked", he managed to survive drinking gasoline when he reached a pit stop along with FreeSmart and Pin.
Coiny is a small orange coin. One of his favorite hobbies is baking dirt. Coiny always knows what teammate will be best at a specific challenge, and he likes to make long speeches that no one else cares about.
Coiny and Firey have been rivals for as long as they can remember, and they still are, even after becoming friends. One result of this rivalry is that, when Firey was picking people to allow onto Dream Island, he picked Coiny last.
Did You Know?: Contrary to what some may tell you, Coiny is actually not a penny.
In "Take the Plunge: Part 1", Coiny is first seen standing on Spongy with Firey. Coiny laughs and tells Firey that he is very easy to slap, proceeding to then slap Firey repeatedly. Golf Ball angrily tells them to stop. In the balancing contest, Coiny angrily shouts at Blocky to wake up when he does a weird position and accidentally pushes him off, but Blocky swings around the beam once again to knock Coiny off, placing him 7th in the contest.
In "Take the Plunge: Part 2", Coiny is picked onto the Squashy Grapes, but only because Snowball suggested to do so when Needle said she preferred him over Snowball, much to his anger. After Firey says Match made a good choice getting him to the Squishy Cherries, Coiny points over to the remaining contestants stating "as if". When Tennis Ball and Golf Ball both agree to get Flower into their team in order to defend themselves, Coiny mocks at them stating they have a crush on each other, but Golf Ball shushes him stating they are only in a platonic relationship.
In the boat race Coiny is the only male player on his team to board the boat. He, Leafy, and Ice Cube almost collide into the Squishy Cherries but end up in the air, and fly over numerous sea creatures. Coiny points out that they passed over the finish line before Ice Cube notices they hit a tree. Coiny and the gang race to the finish, but Coiny slips on Ice Cube's trail when she tries to slide there. The Grapes lose in the end after Pin pokes the ribbon to let the Squishy Cherries win.
In "Barriers and Pitfalls", at Cake at Stake, Coiny is safe with zero votes along with a vast majority of the other Grapes. During the obstacle course challenge, he clashes with Firey but is slapped off the course eventually while they're on the ski lift. The Grapes won after Needle and Teardrop had an advantage over Firey to fill the team tubs.
In "Are You Smarter Than a Snowball?", Coiny was not seen doing much in the episode, other than falling into a hole formed by Woody being kicked by Pin.
Coiny being used as currency by Pen and Eraser
In "Sweet Tooth", after Cake at Stake for the Squishy Cherries, Coiny bakes a dirt cake and is then taken by Eraser and Pen to be used as currency for getting Leafy's cakes, asking to put him down, but they ignore him nonetheless. Coiny gets 14 points for his dirt cake, including 2 for the Announcer since it was inedible, 7 from Flower due to seeing it had "big effort", and 5 from the magical die. His team loses the first challenge, but afterward, he helps his team in a chocolate ball eating contest and they win the second half. Snowball later rips a necktie in a literal tiebreaker, guaranteeing victory for his team for the third time in a row.
In "Bridge Crossing", during the challenge, Coiny is talking to Snowball complaining about how the Announcer wouldn't try his dirt cake, while Snowball decides to "take some business" by throwing contestants off the gorge. Coiny later asks him if he's going to throw him off the cliff. Snowball says no since Coiny is his friend. In another literal tiebreaker, Snowball rips the necktie in half again, giving the Squashy Grapes their fourth victory.
In "Power of Three", when Ice Cube is knocked off the balance beam, Coiny and Needle hurry to island 1 to wait for her. Because of how long it took for Ice Cube to finally arrive, Coiny decides they need a team leader. Ice Cube wanted to be one but was cut of by him, as he claims he'll be the team leader. They were in the lead for a while but ultimately came in last after getting two keys that didn't unlock the door from Island 2 and Snowball plowed straight through them while they were at the finish finally getting a working key. All three get worried when the voting instructions are mentioned.
In "Puzzling Mysteries", during Cake at Stake, Coiny was the last contestant safe, as he got 5 votes out of 18. He also tried to quiet the Announcer telling him to feel for the sound of silence, making it impossible for the Announcer to talk until he called Needle "Needy" to slap Coiny away. Before he also has a chance to ask Needle why she hated when people called her that name, the Announcer immediately sent her to the TLC. His team won the puzzling contest, and the Grapes picked Firey into his team, much to Coiny's disgust while trying to defend himself, but to no luck.
In "Cycle of Life", Coiny was first seen having his foot stepped on by Firey when the Announcer mentioned the contest was a relay-race. After deciding the Grapes should spin the wheel to choose five members to run, he wasn't among the five Squashy Grapes that participated in the race, but Firey was, much to his disgust. His team won the challenge and Coiny surprised and relieved. When the Announcer tells the Grapes that they will get an eliminated player on their team, Coiny asks if they can choose which player, and the Announcer answers no.
In "Insectophobe's Nightmare", Coiny was seen talking with Snowball wondering who would join their team, and the Announcer pops up telling him they'll find out, after he reminds Coiny not to call him a weird speaker box. At Cake at Stake, Coiny protested about eliminated contestants rejoining and getting a Win Token, saying they did worse than them. Firey brags by showing his Win Token from "Power of Three". Coiny is against the idea of the Grapes splitting, as he liked being on the larger team.
He was then put on team Another Name when the Grapes split into two teams of five, unfortunately being placed with Firey again. The two slapped each other for a while during the six-legged-race until Rocky barfed on Coiny's face and mouth. Coinys gets back to arguing when Firey gets excited after noticing they were ahead from the Cherries. They then came up to a tightrope, and Firey's screaming from his fear of heights caused the Cherries to catch up, while Coiny urged his teammates to press forward in a hurry. The Names ultimately came in second after Rocky puked on the ground, causing them to slip.
In "Crybaby!", Coiny continues to get into slap fights with Firey during the crying contest, after having forgotten water was Firey's poison (a line reused from Total Firey Island Book 1, which according to Cary, was the reason for their hating toward each other). During the skiing tiebreaker challenge, the two of them work the skis while standing on Tennis Ball. They eventually trip over Rocky and form into a giant snowball along with the Cherries, resulting in two identical balls that formed first and last place on the contest, so the Announcer did another tiebreaker.
When the handstand contest commenced, the three armless contestants immediately lose, and Rocky barfs on Firey. Coiny laughs at this, and the two get into yet another slap fight, causing them both to fall over. This puts Another Name up for their first elimination and the Squishy Cherries won for the second time in a row.
Firey and Coiny slapping each other nonstop
In "Lofty", Coiny is first seen when he teases Firey after he gets barfed by Rocky, resulting in a long moment where the two slapped each other rapidly. When Golf Ball questions why they do it, stating it was pointless, they both simply call each other jerks. At Cake at Stake, Coiny receives five votes to Firey's three, and the two express their anger about the other not being eliminated. This is much to Tennis Ball's dismay, as he comments about being left with the "slappers". After Golf Ball is eliminated by the Squishy Cherries, the twelve contestants ascend the new stairs to the next contest. Over several days, Coiny and Firey continue slapping each other while on top of Tennis Ball.
Once the balloon contest begins, Coiny laughs at Firey for his fear of heights when the Announcer does a "magic trick". During the challenge, he slaps Firey into Blocky, who is holding a nail, causing him to fall. He briefly greets Tennis Ball when he bounces up into the air. Coiny then manages to shatter Ice Cube, commenting that he's an "ice-cold killer". Blocky then attempts to take out Coiny, but he holds the nail basket in front of him for protection. This fails, however, and the Names lose again.
In "A Leg Up in the Race", Coiny and Firey continue their feud with each other, while Tennis Ball tries to break it up. Coiny then says that Tennis Ball is smarter than Firey after the latter comments about Tennis Ball having no arms. At elimination, Coiny gets 30 votes leading him in the bottom two. Firey laughs, making Coiny slap him and he states that if it was him, he wouldn't go ahead to slap the "most awesome person in the world."
When the Squashy Grapes are choosing who to put on their team, Coiny begs them to choose him over Tennis Ball by giving out a speech to convince them he is right for the team, but ultimately fails when Tennis Ball clarifies if he gets in the team, he'll be slapping Firey all day, ruining his chances. Leafy chooses Tennis Ball on behalf of her team, making Coiny scream, and the Announcer claims that it looks like it's the end for him, while dropping him in the TLC. A giant "OUT" stamp is placed over Coiny's picture in a chart showing BFDI contestants before the episode moves on.
In "Don't Lose Your Marbles", Firey ends up slapping Tennis Ball, after he stated he was used to slapping Coiny, resulting in Tennis Ball being angered and kicking him due to being armless, but Firey doesn't get it, stating it wasn't involved. He continues slapping him until Tennis Ball decides not to work with him anymore.
Coiny drowning in the loaf basket
In "Half a Loaf Is Better Than None", Coiny competes in a contest to rejoin the game by filling his basket with loaves of bread. Initially, he was just behind Flower with three loaves, but after getting to seven, he inexplicably drowned in the bread, much to Firey's delight, teasing him. At the end of the episode, it was revealed that he was still stuck amongst the bread with the others who drowned.
In "Vomitaco", the breadbasket Coiny drowned in is tipped into the TLC, resulting in him falling in with the bread. Pin, Needle, Woody, and Teardrop also fell.
In "Reveal Novum", when Coiny notices the Announcer could actually hear everything they say from inside the TLC, he says it most likely means he did hear him when he called the Announcer something that was cut by the intro, implying he might've actually said a swear word, or something else similar to it. He eventually sees a lake and some trees as the lid opens, and calms Blocky's fear of falling into the water by telling him what he saw. However, the lid closes as they topple down the slope, and Bubble's springy shoes cause them to fall into the water anyway.
The TLC starts leaking and Coiny says they're all going to drown, with Eraser simply saying "Oh well". Coiny is surprised and angered at this mild response and Eraser explains that they just have to push the emergency button and a rescue team will save them. Coiny tells him there is no emergency button and only now is Eraser worried. Later, when the TLC is almost full, Coiny sees the sunrise, causing water to leak out of the TLC. In the stinger, they all get back on land as the sun crushes the recommended characters on the LOL.
In "Gardening Hero", Coiny was put up for rejoining. His rejoin video is him begging the viewers to vote for him, as the viewers are his "friends". Along with pointing out how little sense it makes that Firey is still in while he is not.
In "The Glistening", Coiny votes for Firey to be eliminated, stating he would just vote for him no matter what, angering Firey and causing him to slap himself when he jumps over to miss it. He starts to brag that he is going to win, which causes the Announcer to teleport him back into the TLC. It's revealed that he got 78 votes, the fourth highest, after Flower asked, only to know the number of people she needs to stretch because they didn't vote for her.
In "Insectophobe's Nightmare 2", Coiny says he can hear footsteps outside of the TLC, thinking that meant that they were about to be released. Coiny is then consumed by the Announcer's bugs and dies unless the eliminated contestants faked their deaths as well. He is also seen when the TLC was briefly teleported away, celebrating they were free, but then the TLC comes back and traps them again.
Coiny and Firey hugging each other after finally having an agreement
In "Return of the Hang Glider", Coiny votes for Leafy to win Dream Island and slaps anyone who doesn't vote her. He faints when the winner ends up actually being Firey. He manages to talk Firey into letting into Dream Island, and Firey accepts him after knowing that he had the most connection with him throughout the show.
Coiny doesn't seem to mind that they lost Dream Island, as he tells Pen that two years of battling is nothing. Coiny hugs Firey when they both are able to agree that Flower needs to stop destroying recovery centers, becoming surprised by this when Blocky notices, but Flower is instead disgusted. When Flower is suddenly crushed by a UFO, Coiny asks what is going on. Like most of the contestants, Coiny is angry that Leafy stole Dream Island.
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
Coiny in Battle for Dream Island Again
In "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know", Coiny chases Leafy into the Evil Canyon. Coiny joins BFDIA and comments about how contestants who aren't present not being allowed to compete is unfortunate. After dodging a casual slap from his old nemesis, he decides to side with Donut on his team. With the help of his new teammate, Coiny convinces Pin to switch. In the tug-of-war contest, his team loses in a matter of seconds due to his team having only 3 members compared to the other team's 19.
In "Get Digging", Coiny won the prize and Donut got eliminated. Since they need more members, Coiny forces Teardrop onto his team. For the challenge, Pin tells Coiny that his prize of seeds are yoyleseeds. Coiny shoves them into the ground and they grow into yoyleberries in seconds. Pin crushes the berries into yoylestew and they win. They high five but Teardrop gets in the way and they both talk down to her for doing so.
In "Insectophobe's Nightmare 3", numerous clones of Coiny laugh at Team No-Name as they walk to Cake at Stake. Coiny tells Needle to join his team, threatening her by telling her he would call her "Needy" three times in a row if she refused. Coiny gets his way and Needle switches. Coiny got poisoned during the challenge after about half the bugs were killed. When the glass boxes exploded, the Puffball Speaker Box thought he was a Win Token because the poison turned him green.
In "Zeeky Boogy Doog", Coiny was revived by the new HPRC by Pin. Coiny then recovers Bubble, Bomby, Spongy, Rocky, and Book, though to his shock, Book is still alive. At Cake at Stake, he ended up in the bottom 2 with Teardrop, he was safe, and before Teardrop was flung to the TLC, he asked her if she had any first words. Afterwards, he suggested that his team go for a double dose of new teammates. Coiny forces Bomby to join after threatening to ignite him with Firey. His team made a farm island, but Team No-Name's Dream Island was "glowing", meaning their island was amazing. For his team to win, he had to destroy it, throwing Bomby into Golf Ball's Underground Factory. Bomby landed in the incinerator, thus exploding and killing everyone inside. His team won by default.
In "Get in the Van", Coiny was first seen getting vomited on by Puffball Speaker Box. After Cake at Stake, Pin suggests adding Nickel to their team, but Coiny says they shouldn't because when they get close together, bad things happen. Pin disregards this as nonsense and forces Nickel on their team, which causes the screen to become distorted when he and Nickel get closer. He brags about his team being the largest after FreeSmart and Team No-Name split, only to be corrected by Pin that they are only tied for the largest team. During the beginning of the challenge, his team was far behind the others since they could only walk. He also he suggested that the now-limbless Pin rolls instead of hops.
In "No More Snow!", Coiny tried to get Pin out of glue with Bomby's help, but the two fled when Lightning struck a tree. The tree fell onto Pin as they hid behind a bush, witnessing Pin dying in the process. What remained of the team continued their trek. When the snow cleared up, he calmed down Bomby when a flower pot with petunias randomly fell from the sky. He also pointed out Needle's mistake on the Distance Tracker 2000. When the team falls in the Evil Canyon, Coiny impaled Spongy on the spikes below to keep everyone else safe. He then proceeded to call Needle her much-hated nickname to get the rest of his team up to the top of the cliff. After witnessing Yellow Face throw a burning fuel tank onto Needle and Spongy, the survivors of W.O.A.H. Bunch catch up to FreeSmart. Book tells him that everyone except them is dead, but Coiny is glad since they are technically the final 6. Firey Speaker Box arrives, saying he's not surprised that they managed to lose most of their teammates and destroyed the HPRC. Coiny says it's because he thinks they're stupid when they aren't and claims he's stupid because Firey made him. They then begin cranking the HPHPRCC to make a new HPRC.
In "It's a Monster", Coiny and the others continue cranking the HPHPRCC for 78 days. After that, Coiny then takes a short break, getting angry at Match when she says she's not tired, as she is "super strong". Later, he is worried that the HPHPRCC might explode, but Book says it will likely just disappear without a trace. The latter ends up happening. After FreeSmart leaves they they recover their dead teammates and proceed to walk to the summit of Yoyle Mountain. However, they realize it would be faster if they threatened Puffball into flying them to Yoyleland. Yellow Face says they could threaten her by calling her "Puffy" and Coiny says the idea is perfect. However, the plan goes wrong as Puffball recovers Gelatin and has him freeze Coiny's entire team.
In "The Long-lost Yoyle City", Coiny's team is revealed to be still frozen, besides Yellow Face. Pin and Needle decide to put Coiny and Nickel's frozen bodies next to each other, which creates a portal that shoots out money. Later, his team unfreezes, and he asks where Pin found the huge money bag on the ground, then asks her if she did any "weird tricks" while he was still frozen.
Subsequently, while his team is still walking, Pin tells Coiny about how she couldn't freeze Leafy, even though metal can still freeze. He answers with "Oh! That's because she was made of Yoyle metal. That stuff is unfreezable." Pin gets it now, then asks where Yellow Face is. Later, they eventually find Yellow Face, but he is stuck in slush from the FreeSmart Supervan. Then, he pulls the old "kill and recover" trick on Yellow Face.
A bit later, Pin is tired of walking, and gives Coiny the idea to throw a stick into the Supervan, hoping that one of the buttons could help them. Coiny throws one stick, but it hits Rocky and causes him to get eaten by a Fish Monster. On his second attempt, he succeeds, and a large magnet pops up from the van, pulling the team towards Yoyleland. His team eventually got second (behind FreeSmart), thus winning his team immunity.
In "Well Rested", Coiny is first seen falling along with FreeSmart and W.O.A.H. Bunch from the summit of Yoyle Mountain last episode. When he notices Book is now metal, he laughs and claims he & Book are now matching. Book then mistakes him for Nickel with arms, but Coiny corrects her, saying he just ate too many yoyleberries. Nickel then claims he has arms, surprising him. Everyone then crashes into the ground. Coiny is then seen saying that all of his team members made it back on the ground safely, and so has the brand new team Freesmart.
When he remembers that Team No-Name all died because of Puffball, he suggests that they should all be recovered to prepare them for their elimination. Firey Speaker Box says that it sounds like a great idea, under a pile of yoyleberries. Coiny types all of Team No Name into the HPRC while Needle cranks, recovering them in the process. After the elimination, Coiny, Pin, and Needle run over to the other teams. He then yells if anyone wants to switch to their team in a slowed-down voice. Rocky starts nodding his head, despite his team's disapproval. After Rocky nods his head for a fourth time, confirming the switch, Coiny says it's locked in, with Bomby, Pin and the other members welcoming him to the team. After team switching, Coiny, along with the other remaining contestants all become permanent Yoyleland residents. Due to Pin mixing up him and Nickel, Coiny gets fed a Yellow Tomato and is returned back to normal.
The challenge is to find a building to sleep in. Coiny is seen with his team, with Pin declaring they are the largest team by far. Nickel says they should snatch the largest building to sleep in, with him complimenting Nickel, saying he's not the only big brained coin on his team. Spongy then says he is right, since Nickel is. Coiny then says that it's not enough for their team to get the best sleep, but in order to win, their team must ensure the other teams get the worst sleep imaginable. Needle places a pair of Revolutionary Headphones on Gelatin and Ice Cube. Coiny compliments Needle on how she put the headphones on Gelatin and Ice Cube, their former Power of Three teammate, saying it's brutal. Needle agrees, saying that their team will win.
Coiny is later seen on top of Spongy, walking with his team to Yoyle City's biggest building, the abandoned Aerospace Manufacturing Plant. He and the rest of his team enter inside. Nickel thinks the spaceship beds are race cars, claiming he's never seen something so futuristic in his life. Spongy corrects Nickel, saying they're spaceships, with Pin saying that it's so cool that Spongy is familiar with these. Coiny agrees and says it's amazing, and asks if Spongy has ever been inside a spaceship. Spongy remembers BFDI 21 and says he doesn't like to talk about it. Coiny, while confused, says okay.
Later, when it starts raining inside the building, Coiny (and Bomby) say that some buildings, like this one, are large enough for weather systems to form inside of them, like clouds. Needle finds a dehumidifier and calls it a long thing, but Coiny corrects her and says that if their team hooks it up to the building, then the dehumidifier will absorb all the moisture inside the room into the bottom spout, carrying it up the pipe and spitting it out of the top pipe.
Unfortunately, the FreeSmart Supervan crashes into it, and eventually starts turning it, because of the weight. Everyone tries to get it back in place, but their efforts fail. Both teams now are on opposite ends of the balanced dehumidifier, and start fighting. Coiny fights Book using one of Yellow Face's products, which is labeled as a lightsaber. The teams eventually stop fighting, and W.O.A.H. Bunch tries to disrupt FreeSmart's sleep with spooky stories.
Yellow Face tells a story about Purple Face, but Coiny interrupts since it isn't scaring anybody. Coiny then starts to chant "Evil Leafy" repeatedly which makes the FreeSmart members wince in their sleep. This, however, attracts the actual Evil Leafy to their location, and puts both teams at a stalemate on the dehumidifier (which is now dunking each team as Evil Leafy teleports to them). Ice Cube eventually gets her team the win, and W.O.A.H. Bunch is put up for elimination.
In "Intruder Alert", Coiny is first seen in the intro song, saying how's it going. Later, Firey Speaker Box used the trick of pushing Coiny and Nickel together to generate money for the show. Later, Coiny is seen at the Cake at Stake place with the rest of Woah Bunch. When the vote count is revealed, he wishes it was 128 lower. He is safe with 5,407 dislikes and recieves a slice of Asbestos Cake, along with Nickel. Firey Speaker Box calls him and Nickel his money-makers before he corrects himself and calls him his friends.
Coiny says hooray when he gets his slice but with arms after Nickel says hooray after recieving a slice of Asbestos Cake. Later when Rocky is eliminated and bounces off the LOL, he says that that's not good and says that shouldn't Rocky go inside the LOL, with Firey Speaker Box agreeing with him, and using a grappling hook to try to open the LOL, but due to TV having the key, he can't. After the elimination, Fries spins the prize wheel and Coiny is again seen with his team. The challenge is to build a new dungeon for the future eliminated contestants. Spongy says that Coiny will soon be him, with Coiny getting upset and kicking him.
In the challenge, Pin says that everyone hates farms, with Coiny saying who doesn't. Pin thinks their loser chamber should be farmed themed, with Yellow Face saying that her idea sucks with Nickel agreeing with him. Nickel then asks Spongy if he has any ideas, with him saying he has none, but when he asks Needle, she says she does have one and asks Nickel if he remembers the spaceships, which he does. Needle says they could dissassemble them and use the raw metal to build the new loser chamber.
Nickel says it's a great idea and tells Woah Bunch to go to the Aerospace Manufacturing Plant now. When they all arrive, it's filled to the top with rain water, and Needle says that there's way too much, and that it's covering the ships. Coiny then says he brought drinking straws and gives them to everyone and tells them to start sucking, with Spongy saying he already does. When Needle says that the water tastes bad, Coiny asks if she wants to win or not, with Needle saying that she thinks she's gonna puke. Yellow Face offers Needle powder packets to give it that explosion of refreshing great flavor, with Needle declining and with Yellow Face offering to make the price 10% off and more. When Pin thinks their team needs a better leader, Coiny agrees, shocking Pin.
Later, Needle finally accepts the powder packets when Yellow Face offers it for 200% off. Yellow Face gives it to Needle and she pours it in, she tastes it and says that it tastes so much better and that she doesn't feel like throwing up anymore, with Pin agreeing and saying that it's a explosive fruity flavor. Coiny says that it's so good that he can't stop drinking it. Woah Bunch drinks all the water up, and with the spaceships no longer being submerged underwater, they all cheer saying that all the water is gone. They go down to the spaceships and Nickel tells Coiny, Needle, Spongy and Yellow Face to dismantle the ships, with them all agreeing to do so.
Coiny and Needle dismantle a couple ships before Pin says that it's a little sad that they are destroying spacefaring technology just for a silly little contest, with Coiny and Pin ripping Pin in half, killing her. Nickel then tells their team to fold the box metal into a cool scrap shape, which they all do. Nickel then tells them to add handcuffs, crushers, chainsaws, and photos of Flower's hideous face. Coiny places them on the box in disgust. Needle asks Nickel on why he wants their chamber to have such cruel punishments, with Nickel quoting that Firey Speaker Box said "The more secure, the better!", with Nickel asking if he right, with Needle agreeing with him. Nickel says that tere's no way any future eliminated contestant will get past those nightmares. Spongy asks Nickel what will happen if he gets eliminated, with Nickel imaging himself getting crushed and cut by the crushers and chainsaws, screaming. Nickel then says that it sounds hard, but if he messes up enough to get eliminated, he wants to endure the torment he deserves, and tells Needle to double the crushers, with her agreeing and adding them in the chamber.
Later when Firey Speaker Box moves on to check Woah Bunch's chamber, he compliments them and says they totally went brutal with the crushers, chainsaws, and Flower posters, with him asking if they really are, with Nickel comfirming it. Firey Speaker Box then says that's an automatic 9/10 for effort, with Needle saying they'll take it. with Coiny's team being immune first. After the challenge ended, Coiny congratulates his team members on the win, with Needle saying to celebrate, they should all these eat firey hot chilli peppers she has. Nickel says it's a good idea and they all eat a pepper.
After eating it, Coiny's stomach grumbles and says that he feels queasy, with Spongy laughing and mocking him, saying that he can't handle the heat. Coiny then asks where Bomby has been this whole time. Needle then asks Yellow Face if he knows where Bomby is, with Yellow Face getting nervous and hesitating to tell. Coiny then tells him that he hopes the grape-flavored powder wasn't Bomby's gunpowder. Yellow Face gets nervous, with Coiny shouting at him and asking him again if it was it.
Yellow Face claims that Bomby was purple and didn't know anything, with Needle getting upset and claiming that he murdered Bomby. Nickel then is concerned and says that firey hot chilli peppers and gunpowder in his stomach is not a good combo, with all of WOAH Bunch screaming and them all exploding, killing them ( including Coiny) and also destroying their loser chamber in the process.
In "Meaty", Coiny is first seen on top of the Eiffel Tower with the rest of his team. Needle tells that her team color is purple, looking worried. Pin asks what is wrong with purple, with Yellow Face behind her looking angry. He says that he refuses to do anything purple realted. Pin tells Coiny that Gelatin’s Shadeshouse invented new sunglasses that make yellow things look purple and purple things look yellow. Coiny asks where he could find glasses like that, and Pin tells him he would find them at Gleatin's Shadeshouse and that they rebranded from Gelatin's Steakhouse to Gelatin's Shadehouse. Coiny agrees to get them and runs down the Eiffel Tower and into Gelatin's Shadehouse.
Coiny is then seen trying on various sunglasses at Gelatin's Shadehouse, saying that Ladle fashion is in, but it's not quite his style. He then pulls out a butcher's knife, saying that he doesnt feel comfortorable with Yellow Face wearing something like this. He then tries on a ketchup bottle sunglasses, wondering why they made it out of a ketchup bottle. Barbecue Sauce says that it used to be a steakhouse. Coiny is suprised by him and asks who he is. BBQ Sauce says he goes by BBQ Sauc, but also says that he hasn't heard that name in a while. Coiny then says he is super hungry and asks for anything to eat. BBQ Sauce then sings a song about steak and how it has protein and how everyone will grill it. Coiny says it sounds appetizing and asks for BBQ Sauce to serve him some meat now. BBQ Sauce then calls him dumb and says that he was only joking and asks him if he sees a kitchen around here. Coiny says that he doesn't.
BBQ Sauce tells him that Gelatin pivoted from steak to sunglasses after the rancid recession of 2013, and after that, all his savory friends had to either go find jobs or get killed and get turned into consumable eyewear. Coiny exclaims in disgust and throws away the sunglasses he was holding and BBQ Sauce says that the sunglasses he was wearing was named Hot Sauce, not Ketchup. Coiny apologizes. BBQ Sauce then says that he came in here to buy sunglasses, and he doesn't want to get in his way, and tells him to buy some blue and green sunglasses.
BBQ Sauce then rings a bell, which summons Gelatin to his shadehouse. Gelatin jumps over to the cashier desk and asks if Coiny would like to purchase a product. Coiny says yes and shows him the blue and green sunglasses. Gelatin sniffs it and says that he smells last month's BBQ Sauce, even after last month's fumigation. Coiny nervously says that he doesn't think so, and kicks BBQ Sauce out of the shadehouse, slamming the door. Gelatin says guess not, and says Coiny has a nice choice of sunglasses. He asks how he would like to pay, and Coiny realizes he forgot to carry cash on him. Gelatin says he could pay with himself. Coiny agrees to that idea and so does Gelatin. Gelatin puts Coiny in the cash register, and says to have a good day and closes up shop. He turns off the lights and leaves.
Later, Pin says that Coiny has been gone at Gelatin's Shadehouse for a long time, and asks if they should check on him. Yellow Face says they should. Pin and Yellow Face arrive at the shadehouse, and Yellow Face says it smells so " meaty meaty" in here. Pin agrees but asks if Coiny is in here. Coiny screams for help, but his voice is muffled by the cash register. Pin says that she hears Coiny's voice, but asks where it's coming from. Yellow Face tells Pin to use his 50% off Coiny Detector to find his exact location. Pin says it's very convenient, and tells Yellow Face that it's pointing in the way of the cash register. Yellow Face tells Coiny to come out wherever he is. Pin says that he must be somewhere around this side of the store, but she doesn't know exactly. She wishes something sharp and pointy could point them into his exact location, and the Eiffel Tower coveniently points to the cash register. Yellow Face tells Pin to grab it, but she says she can't without her arms. The Eiffel Tower flings the cash register into space with Coiny still inside.
In "Catch These Hands", Coiny is first seen flying in space, with the PSB saying that he's 10 billion miles away, and that she doesn't have the budget to retreive him. Pin says this is extremely unfair to Coiny but PSB asks Pin to grab him with her "arms", upsetting Pin. Coiny is later seen again talking to himself when his voice suddenly is swapped with Needle's, with his voice sounding like the latter. He says that his life makes no sense, and groans. He is later shown to have died from asphyxiation in space.
In "Taste the Sweetness", Coiny is finally recovered from space using the HPRC. After the intro, Pin welcomes him back on the team. However, Coiny realizes he still sounds like Needle. Later, Coiny is one of the first people to notice Ice Cube's "beautiful face", and decides to switch to Freesmart, followed by many more W.O.A.H. Bunchers. Coiny is then on the Beautiful Face Devotion Institute. During the challenge, Coiny cries along with the rest of the BFDI when Ice Cube is shattered into pieces by Needle. Golf Ball commands Coiny, along with Ruby and Tennis Ball to make the ice cream. Inside Gelatin's Steakhouse, the the three try to open the metal door that goes into the ingredient room.
When Tennis Ball instead tries putting in the password, Coiny decides to go to Barbecue Sauce to ask him what the password is. Pineapple tells Coiny that they could not accept anymore customers, especially him. Barbecue Sauce tells Pineapple that Coiny gets a free pass, since he saved him from a close encounter with Gelatin. However, when Coiny tries to ask him, Barbecue Sauce gets suspicious because his voice sounds like Needle's. However, he gets so scared and frustrated that Needle and Coiny's voices switch back to their respective selves. Coiny fully asks Barbecue Sauce for the password, removing any suspicion. He tells him that the password is 21768. After putting the password in, Coiny and Ruby ravage the ingredients room for ingredients for ice cream. Coiny finds Gelatin's pre-baked ice cream, but Ruby points out how it expired in August 2012 (the time of BFDIA 5e). He puts it back, but notices Tennis Ball's absence.
Later, Coiny and Ruby finish the ice cream, and they give it to Pin. When Book wastes their ice cream on Spongy, he tells them to make more, and Coiny says he's on it. Later, Coiny along with Ruby make 500 gallons of ice cream, however, the sprinklers (turned on by Pineapple) cause the ice cream to melt, making Coiny sad that it will please nobody. Coiny, as well as the rest of the Beautiful Face Devotion Institute lose the challenge, making him up for elimination.
In "Lots of Mud", Coiny announces when they arrive at the elimination area. He is the first contestant safe and celebrates this. After the elimination, Golf Ball flips Ice Cube over while she's doing her beautiful face, and Coiny, along with everyone else, finds it ugly and leaves the team. When coming up with their team name, Coiny rejects "The Bad Face Destruction Institute" in favor of something with more emphasis of how he hates the ugly face. Based on the idea of others, he ends up calling the team "Water's Open Aperture Hater Bunch", otherwise known as W.O.A.H. Bunch.
Upon the contest wheel learning on "Rip Flower's Petals Off", Coiny immediately rips her petal off before blowing it up alongside Bomby with a firecracker. After recieving snorkels to dive underwater with, Coiny tries to give one to Pin, but can't find her face to put it on. He eventually gets worried about if Pin drowned without them knowing and tests it by seeing if her body floats. However, her body instead sinks to the bottom of the lake. He later tastes fish food being poured down his snorkel (by Vegemite and Black and White Cookie) and coughs it out. That same fish food attracts a Fish Monster who coils around Coiny as he tries to fend it off, but is later cut in half after Needle is attracted towards it.
Coiny then runs back to the store, asking Tennis Ball if the keys are there, learning that one of them is behind a door and the other two are traps. He then finds Pin, happy that she's alive but calls her useless for not saying what door it is and even considers crushing her. He is also initially annoyed when Pin starts oozing while he tries opening the doors, but then realises this is her way of telling of the door is safe or not. He eventually opens a door with a few bugs behind it, quickly jumping around with them before finding the key. He thanks Pin and gifts her a bug, which poisons her. LRLD then see Coiny with the key and all try taking it from him, with Coiny shattering Ruby with Pencil and then dulling her out by scribbling her lead on Book. Book is able to take the key away from Coiny by unfurling his hand and unlocks the petal, but Coiny knocks her away and is the one to actually rip the petal off, deeming his team safe. He calls this "unfurling Book's brain".
In "Insectophobe's Nightmare 4", Ruby asks everyone about their thoughts on FreeSmart, and Coiny, fearing the shrink ray, steps back before lying that he likes the team. However, Pin is shrunk for not supporting FreeSmart, which horrifies Coiny. During the challenge, Coiny directs everyone to throw bugs at Fries, who has the disadvantage of being a solo team, however he quickly dodges their attacks. Among the chaos, Coiny repeatedly kills Tennis Ball. When the fashion store is about to explode, he jokingly comments on Bomby’s expertise, and gets slapped by him.
After escaping the explosion, Coiny chases Fries along with Bomby. Luckily for Fries, a fumigator backpack passes by, and Fries grabs it and flies away. Coiny is frustrated until Bomby suggests throwing Pin at the backpack to stop Fries. Coiny is reluctant, but Bomby does it anyway. Pin hits the backpack, it bursts, and Fries falls. Coiny praises Bomby for his quick thinking, but their victory is short-lived as Evil Leafy suddenly appears behind them.
In a panicked attempt to defend themselves, they unleash the bugs, only for Evil Leafy to consume them. Just as all hope seems lost, Coiny notices Needle's water-filled icon in the corner of his vision. Seizing the opportunity, he grabs the icon and urges Bomby to leap with him. However he refuses, so Coiny takes the water-filled icon and jumps off the cliff, squeezing as much water out as he can on his way down, which causes a flood. Coiny survives and returns the icon, whilst Bomby dies to Evil Leafy. Meanwhile, in Coiny and Pin's subconscious, Pin devises a plan for change.
Later, Coiny reaches to the auditorium, where he encounters a blue "Ruby" (actually her sisters). Ruby tries to kill Coiny, causing the audience to restrain her. Before being silenced, Ruby asks Needle to save Freesmart. Coiny attempts to get Needle to kill Ruby in favour of W.O.A.H. Bunch, but Needle, remembering Pencil's advice, realizes she must sacrifice Coiny to advance. She kills him, and Freesmart is declared safe while Coiny’s team faces elimination.
Also, in the post credits scene, Pin talks to Coiny about her plan in the final subconscious. She mentions that there's one place where she can be her whole self again, and Coiny asks where that is. She says that it's far, far away, but in order for them to get there, they would have to get "compacted".
In "Well, Look Who It Is!", Coiny gets recovered by Ruby. Seconds later, she recovers Pin, and Needle remarks on how easy it was due to Pin's size. Ruby credits herself and they high-five. The scene briefly shifts to Coiny and Pin's subconscious, where Pin asks if Coiny heard that. Coiny confirms he did and vows that Freesmart will pay. They recover Yellow Face, and take turns carrying him to the WTF, and laugh at all the other eliminated contestants for losing. As they laugh, Coiny snatches away the grapple gun from Gelatin and departs.
Subsequently, in Coiny and Pin's subconscious, Pin's voice interchanges between her normal voice and her robotic one. Pin outlines her plan in detail:
Transport her body through Goiky Highway, regardless of the time it takes.
Locate the trash compactors.
Teleport her body into them.
List a series of fruits (the "secret mantra") to lower the compactor, crushing her.
With these instructions clear, Coiny sets off. He begins by traversing Goiky Highway, carrying Pin’s body with steadfast resolve. After completing each task, he continues his journey and eventually digs toward the Earth's core. On his way down, he reaches an inverted planet, but is quickly corrected by Pinecone, who tells him that the actual term is actually "Buried Forest, Deciduously Insulated." Later, Coiny continues digging and eventually reaches the bottom. His body melts the rest of the way to the earth's inner core, where he meets Pin. She uses her freeze breath to restore Coiny to his original state. Coiny asks why she looks so different and inquires about their location, but a loud voice roars "GET OUT," prompting Pin to urge him to leave immediately.
Coiny pulls out his grapple gun and escapes with Pin. He manages to climb out of the hole safely but struggles to pull Pin up with him. As her voice alternates between her normal and text-to-speech tones, Pin expresses pride in Coiny, saying they did this together. Inside, the LOL prisoners witness the events and quickly use Fanny's fan and a lever to fly away. Eventually, Coiny manages to pull Pin out of the hole, but she reverts to her most recent form, not having her limbs, face, and size. Coiny stands next in front of the feeble Pin in despair, then the screen starts to black out, ending it.
In "PointyPointyPointy ♫", Coiny warns everyone about the bugs, and Bomby reminds him that the bugs are the hosts now and that it's time for Cake at Stake. At the Cake at Stake, Pin ends up winning the prize, so Coiny congratulates her for it. Fries tells her to hurry up and spin the wheel, but since she can't due to having no limbs, her default prize is "Excruciating Pain for 2,763 years." This gets a laugh out of Fries, upsetting Coiny, and he expresses his frustration of Pin always being the butt of people's jokes. He volunteers to spin the wheel on her behalf and intentionally stops the wheel on "Regain your face, size, and a State-of-the-Art Mech Suit." As Pin rises, Coiny, along with Bomby and Nickel begin chanting: "Pin shall rise" and "Return of the W.O.A.H". Once Pin got her face and size back, Coiny tells her that he's happy to see her complete again and asks her what does she want to to do now, and Pin replies she wants revenge on FreeSmart.
Moving on to the dislikes, Coiny and Pin are revealed to be safe back to back, with 3,453 and 4,609 dislikes, respectively. Coiny gives Pin a high five, and they receive poisoned instruments as their prizes. Meanwhile, Fries is talking to Barf Bag on the phone, which confuses Coiny since Barf Bag is in the Locker of Losers. Moments later, the LOL falls on Spongy, killing him and the bugs. With the bugs gone, Barf Bag is nominated as the new host, but Match wants to host as well. They argue over who should take the role, and Coiny suggests that everyone in the LOL should host, which everyone agrees to.
For the next contest, the contestants need to get into pairs. Coiny immediately asks Pin if she wants to team up, and she agrees. After the teams have been sorted, they are taken to a spiral with the bunk bed at the top, and are tasked with completing mini-contests across five different islands to advance to the bunk bed and win immunity.
The challenge begins, and the teams quickly head toward the first island. On the way, Pin tells Coiny that thanks to her mech suit, they are currently in the lead, but Coiny corrects her, saying they are actually last. As Coiny and Pin reach the vines leading to the first island, Coiny expresses concern about whether Pin's mech suit can climb the vines. Pin confidently assures him that it can, and they begin climbing together. As they ascend, Coiny mentions how excited he is to compete alongside her again, and Pin, with determination, replies that she's excited for revenge.
Coiny suddenly notices Pin's power cable dangling precariously and warns her to be careful. Unfortunately, the warning comes too late—Pin's power cable disconnects, causing her to fall to the ground, breaking her mech suit upon impact. Coiny quickly pulls out his phone and orders more extension cables for her, but in his haste, he loses his balance and tumbles down as well, joining Pin on the ground.
Coiny and Pin, after narrowly escaping Evil Leafy by climbing the vines, finally reach Donut's island. Spotting Book and Ruby's jetpack, they swiftly seize the opportunity and grab it. Without hesitation, Coiny and Pin soar toward the next island, where they’re faced with a peculiar challenge: eating parts of the island. Coiny gives it a try but quickly finds himself unable to stomach the strange substance. Pin, thinking fast, sends the island chunks through a garbage disposal, which Dora accepts, and allows them to proceed.
Coiny dives into the waterfall leading to the next island, whilst holding onto Pin. As they ascend, Coiny gets shocked by the extension cables connected to Pin’s mech suit, so he swims the rest of the way whilst holding Pin out of the water to protect her. Upon reaching the island, they come across a shipwreck that reminds Coiny of an urban legend about Teardrop being a pirate. Excited, Coiny asks Pin to take a photo of him with the ship. Pin agrees but accidentally runs over Popcorn while backing up. Just as she’s about to take the photo, Milkdrop hugs Pin, ruining the shot. Coiny asks if he can see the photo and Pin says sure, but adds that Milkdrop gifted her a rocket as a thank you. Curious, Coiny presses a button on the rockets, and they immediately zoom toward the next island.
Coiny and Pin, now on Match's island, are greeted by Match herself, who explains that the island is dedicated to building matchsticks like her. Coiny asks if that's true, and when Match confirms, Pin finds it gross. Just then, Match’s friends arrive, and Coiny asks what the challenge is. Match explains that they need to collect a nightcap and then build a raft to ride a volcano to the final island.
With the instructions clear, Coiny and Pin begin constructing their raft out of matchsticks. However, when they place it on the lava, the raft burns instantly. Undeterred, they decide to rebuild it using metal, but the process proves to be much more difficult than they anticipated. As Coiny and Pin continue working on their metal raft, Pin makes a disparaging comment about the island, which upsets Match. The argument that follows makes the atmosphere tense and causes Coiny to accidentally hurt his hand. Pin scolds Coiny to be more careful. Later, Coiny notices that Match's friends are jumping off a cliff and informs her of the situation. Match, seemingly unfazed, responds that she’s already aware of it.
Finally, Coiny and Pin complete their metal raft, ready to tackle the final leg of the challenge. However, Fries, seizing the moment, swoops in and steals their raft to use for himself and Bomby. Despite Coiny and Pin's protests, Fries dismisses their concerns and takes off with the raft.
Bomby, observing the situation and recognizing Coiny and Pin as fellow W.O.A.H. Bunch members, decides to help them out. He rips off a section of the raft and tosses it to Coiny and Pin, with the former gratefully accepting the makeshift raft piece. They use it to climb the volcano, determined to reach the final island.
On arrival, Coiny and Pin face their final task: to sing a lullaby that Puffball likes in order to advance to the bunk beds and secure immunity. Coiny hands the mic to Pin and she begins singing, but unfortunately, it's a song Puffball dislikes, so their platform doesn't rise.
Subsequently, they are given another chance so Coiny steps up to sing. Pin, eager to contribute, interrupts him and starts singing her song again. Despite her enthusiasm, Puffball still rejects the song. Coiny attempts to sing again, but before he can start, their platform abruptly flings them away. Puffball informs them that they can’t sing twice in a row if other teams are waiting to perform. Pin is confused, believing the other teams weren't here yet, until Ruby, Book, Pencil, Needle and Bubble suddenly appear behind them, intensifying their frustration. Needle performs a heartfelt song that moves Puffball to tears, and she and Pencil advance to the bunk beds. This leaves Coiny and Pin's duo, along with Ruby and Book’s duo, in the bottom two.
Coiny as he prepares to sing his song.
Pin tries to submit another song, but Book reminds them they can’t until she and Ruby have performed. Onstage, Ruby puts out a microphone and replays Pin’s earlier song but with autotune, which distresses Pin deeply. Coiny asks if she's okay and tries to calm her down, but Pin, furious, struggles to control her emotions. Puffball accepts Ruby and Book’s performance, and as they near the bunk beds, Pin’s mech suit malfunctions dramatically. Electrical surges from the suit strike the previous islands, leading to Bubble’s demise and sending Book and Ruby all the way back to the beginning.
Amid the chaos, Pin manages to sing a different song that Puffball enjoys, allowing them to advance to the bunk beds. Coiny, bewildered by the events, opts to stay silent and settles into bed, securing their immunity.
In "Spore Day", Coiny and Pin are standing on Puffball's island when a package arrives for them. Coiny assumes it's the battery pack they've been waiting for, so he opens it and attaches it to Pin's mech suit. Pin is delighted, as the battery allows her to move freely, unlike before when her movement was restricted by cables. Later, during Cake at Stake, the LOLers read out comments posted by fans, including one that criticizes Ruby for nearly causing Coiny and Pin to lose last episode. They also refer to her as a stealer, which Coiny wholeheartedly agrees with. As the votes are revealed, Pin thanks Coiny for digging to the center of the earth for her. Coiny casually replies "no problem", before adding that they now get to see which "stealer" will face Pin's revenge.
For the next challenge, the contestants are tasked with forming groups of three. Coiny immediately turns to Pin, Bomby, and Nickel, asking if they'd like to team up. They all agree, but since there are four of them, they're forced to turn down Nickel and advise him to find another group. After everyone settles into their teams, a massive wall suddenly emerges from the ground, separating all the contestants from their chosen teammates. Confusion spreads among the group until Balloony explains that the teams are actually based on the shape engraved on their mats, revealing that Coiny is unexpectedly grouped with Pencil and Fries. Blocky then names their team "The Hearts," much to Coiny's reluctant acceptance.
Barf Bag steps forward to explain the next challenge: the teams must enter the birdhouse in front of them, and the first team to get all their members inside will win immunity, while the rest will be up for elimination. Eager to win, Fries tries forcing himself into the birdhouse, but it's much too small for him (or any of the contestants for that matter) to fit. Coiny attempts to squish Fries down to make him fit as Pencil cheers them on, but it’s no use. Frustrated, Coiny turns to Pencil, insisting it's her turn now. Uncomfortable with the idea, Pencil quickly backs out. As she scans the area, she notices another team holding a shrink ray from afar and suggests they use that to shrink themselves. Just then, Fries, having recovered, agrees it’s a solid plan.
Fries grabs the shrink ray from Tennis Ball and hastily uses it on Pencil, but she ends up shrinking far too small, so Coiny scolds Fries for the mistake. Suddenly, Pin lunges at Fries, causing him to fumble and drop the shrink ray, which Coiny swiftly catches. Book, seeing this, charges at Coiny, and he tries to blast her with the shrink ray, but Book dodges each attempt. She eventually closes in and traps Coiny between her pages. Desperate, Coiny pleads with Pencil to save him, and Pencil quickly climbs into Pin’s mech suit to help.
Meanwhile, Coiny and Book continue struggling for control of the shrink ray. Just as Book manages to gain the upper hand, Fries leaps at her, creating a chaotic scuffle involving Coiny, Book, Fries, and Pin. In the chaos, the shrink ray accidentally hits the birdhouse, making it even smaller than before. As everyone is momentarily stunned by the birdhouse’s new tiny size, Coiny slyly sneaks the shrink ray from Book’s grasp and escapes with Fries.
Later, Coiny and Fries are seen in hot pursuit of Tennis Ball, but Fries suddenly halts when he notices Needle and Bomby about to enter the birdhouse. Thinking quickly, Fries grabs both the shrink ray and the birdhouse, and begins spinning himself around in circles. Coiny, the other contestants, and even some of the recommended characters cheer him on as he builds momentum. With a mighty throw, Fries hurls the birdhouse into the air, and it lands perfectly perched on top of a tall tree.
Fries then instructs Coiny to tie down the enemy (referring to Bomby), so Coiny swiftly jumps into action; securing Bomby to a chair before he can reach the birdhouse. Once they’ve restrained Bomby, they turn their attention to Tennis Ball, with Coiny declaring that it’s the end of the line for him. Fries chimes in, mocking Tennis Ball for his “nerd nonsense.” Unfazed, Tennis Ball introduces them to his growth ray, ready to turn the tables.
Coiny warns Tennis Ball that he should know better than to underestimate his genius. Tennis Ball explains that his plan is to make the birdhouse big enough for him to fit inside. As he aims the growth ray at the birdhouse, Fries cleverly shifts its trajectory, redirecting it toward Bomby. Tennis Ball quickly warns Bomby to dodge, which he manages to do just in time, causing the ray to hit Ivory instead. Amidst the chaos, Coiny turns to Fries and bets that Pencil is doing a much better job than they are at that moment.
Later, the birdhouse is reduced to an even smaller size, landing in a bubble. Coiny tells Fries to just fire the growth ray at the birdhouse, emphasizing that they should target only the birdhouse so they can walk inside. Fries agrees and prepares to take his shot. However, Tennis Ball warns him not to shoot at any lead particles or historical objects, explaining that hitting either would wreak havoc on the ecosystem. Ignoring the warning, Fries takes aim and fires, but instead of the birdhouse, he accidentally hits a fish monster, causing it to grow in size.
Coiny exclaims that he believes the fish monster is not the birdhouse, as the creature tries to eat them. Thinking quickly, Fries tosses the fish monster away and redirects it toward Bomby. Realizing the predicament they’re in, Coiny decides to change their plan and suggests they shrink themselves instead. They jump into the water, but in the process, Fries accidentally gets poisoned by the lead.
Coiny points out that everyone got lead in their head, asking if they’re dead. Book, with a hint of sarcasm, replies, “well said". Just then, Tennis Ball arrives, and Coiny excitedly remarks that it’s so good to see him again. Tennis Ball, however, nonchalantly replies, “whatever". As the situation escalates, Bomby and Needle attempt to enter the birdhouse, but they too end up getting poisoned by the lead.
Desperate, Coiny turns to Tennis Ball and asks if he knows a way to remove the lead from people. Reluctantly, Tennis Ball hands him some eyedroppers to extract the lead. Coiny uses the eyedroppers on Pencil and Fries, while Book and Tennis Ball help their respective teammates as well. They all cheer in relief at their successful extraction. However, when they all attempt to reach the birdhouse again, they keep getting poisoned by the lead. Realizing that they can’t get any further, Pin angrily blames Fries for putting the lead there in the first place.
In retaliation, Book aims her zap shooter at Fries. To protect himself, Fries shoves Coiny in the way, and the zap shooter hits Coiny instead. The scene shifts to all of the contestants continuously shrinking each other to an even smaller size than before, until Tennis Ball realises that they're now at the atomic level.
Tennis Ball concludes that maybe they could neutralize the lead from their smaller size. Curious, Coiny wonders what would happen if he were to remove a proton from the lead. As he proceeds to do so, Tennis Ball warns him that he just made thallium, which is even worse. Undeterred, Coiny removes another proton, only for Tennis Ball to inform him that he just created mercury, which isn’t any better. Finally, Coiny removes one last proton and, to his surprise, Tennis Ball announces that it’s now gold, which is safe to touch.
With newfound hope, Coiny turns to Pencil and Fries, instructing them to pluck three protons off each atom. They jump into action, and as they do, they inadvertently throw the protons at the other contestants, resulting in them getting poisoned. Despite the chaos, Coiny, Pencil, and Fries make their way towards the birdhouse, ultimately winning the challenge for their team.
In the stinger, the scene shifts to them just outside the birdhouse, excitement building as they eagerly anticipate what awaits them inside. However, their enthusiasm quickly dissipates as the interior is revealed to be nothing but a large pile of chairs, a BFDI DDS, and a dirty mattress. Their excitement turns to disappointment as they confront the underwhelming reality of their reward.
In "Respect to the Wicked," Coiny and the other BFDIA contestants experiment with the atoms inside the birdhouse. Their meddling goes awry when two atoms collide, resulting in a massive explosion. The blast launches the water droplet they inhabit onto the window of the Locker of Losers (LOL), where it eventually finds its way into Balloony's eye.
Inside Balloony's eye, the group initiates Cake at Stake. Coiny, Fries, and Pencil are immediately declared safe for having been the only team to successfully enter the birdhouse in the previous episode. When it comes to revealing the likes, all eyes turn to TV to announce the winner and the associated prize. However, the results screen is completely obscured by several layers of duct tape. Book points out to Balloony that they can't see the results, prompting Coiny to explain that the duct tape needs to be removed. After peeling off the layers, the results are finally revealed: Tennis Ball has earned the most likes, securing a reward.
Later, Pillow sends dust into Balloony's eye, triggering a reflexive blink. The contestants panic as the eye closes, leaving them seconds away from being crushed. Tennis Ball attempts to delay the inevitable by using reinforcements, but his efforts only buy a fleeting moment of safety before the support collapses. The eye shuts completely, and the contestants are crushed. Moments later, Balloony recovers them, restoring them unharmed.
Regrouping to resume the Cake at Stake, Coiny, Fries, and Pencil are declared safe. Coiny, relishing the victory, dramatically slices the grain of rice reward into smaller portions. They each take a piece, savoring it slowly and theatrically to mock the other contestants. Tennis Ball, annoyed by their antics, remarks that such gloating is unnecessary.
As the elimination narrows to the bottom two, Pin and Bomby stand in anticipation. When Pin is announced safe, Coiny immediately celebrates, lifting her into the air and spinning her around with joy, relieved that she remains in the game for another day. Bomby, on the other hand, expresses his sadness at leaving W.O.A.H. Bunch, telling them he'll miss them as he prepares to depart. Coiny and Pin offer awkward, unreassuring goodbyes, and Bomby is soon launched to the Weak Trembling Fortress (WTF).
After the elimination, the contestants are transported to the grasslands, leaving only eight players remaining in the game. Pencil takes pride in surpassing her previous record of 9th place, but Pin remarks that she beat her own record of 20th place over a year ago. Reflecting on it, Pin quickly realizes her "achievement" isn't particularly impressive. Coiny notices her disappointment and tries to cheer her up, urging Pencil and Fries to celebrate Pin’s milestone. The trio enthusiastically, and sarcastically, shower Pin with awards and badges, their exaggerated tone grating on her nerves.
Shifting the conversation, Coiny turns to Fries and Pencil, suggesting they stick together as a team since they worked well together in the last challenge. They agree at first, but when Coiny suggests they include Pin; Pencil abruptly changes her mind. She announces that she's rejoining FreeSmart before walking away without another word. Left behind, Coiny decides to return to W.O.A.H. Bunch with Pin, while Fries opts to remain unaffiliated.
Coiny gathers the remaining members of W.O.A.H. Bunch, but only Pin and Nickel show up. Observing how small their team has become, Coiny remarks on their dwindling numbers. Pin bluntly responds that it’s about to shrink further and promptly tells Nickel to leave. Without protest, Nickel walks away. Coiny criticizes Pin for making such a disadvantageous decision, but Pin dismisses his concerns, stating she simply didn’t like Nickel. Coiny sighs and brushes it off with a resigned "whatever."
Turning his attention to Needle, Coiny asks if she’d consider rejoining W.O.A.H. Bunch. Needle, currently aligned with FreeSmart, hesitates. Pin jumps in, encouraging Needle by offering her full membership if she switches back. This tempts Needle, and she’s on the verge of agreeing when Pencil interjects, questioning if Needle is seriously considering it.
Coiny asserts with confidence that Needle has always been loyal to W.O.A.H. Bunch, claiming she’s been with them since the beginning. Tennis Ball chimes in, casually pointing out that Needle was actually on Team No-Name first. Coiny and Pencil ignore him. The former turns to Needle once more, renewing his pitch for her to rejoin W.O.A.H. Bunch. Pencil interrupts, telling Coiny that Needle can speak for herself before adding that Needle has already expressed her desire to stay with FreeSmart.
Both teams now focus their attention on Needle, each urging her to pick a side. Overwhelmed by the mounting pressure, Needle ultimately decides on an unconventional solution: she’ll compete for both teams. This decision leaves both groups visibly disappointed, though Coiny lightheartedly remarks that at least he’s "kind of" gotten "needy" back. Annoyed by the nickname, Needle promptly slaps him. Pencil remarks that she’s the only one allowed to call Needle by that name—only to receive a slap from Needle as well.
As the contestants prepare for the "scavenger tag" contest, Balloony instructs them to choose a prized possession that will represent their team. Needle approaches Pin and Coiny, asking what they should pick as their trinket. Coiny eagerly suggests their dirt cake, but Pin disagrees, asserting that it’s not their trinket. Coiny stubbornly insists that it is, and Pin begrudgingly agrees, albeit with some reluctance.
yes, it is.
Once all the teams have selected their trinkets, Balloony announces that the next step is to hide them. Each team rushes off in different directions, searching for the perfect hiding spot for their prized possessions. After a brief period, the teams regroup, and Balloony explains the challenge: each team must find the other teams' trinkets and tag them in order to eliminate them from the game. The last team to have their trinket tagged will win immunity, securing their safety.
With the challenge underway, the contestants scramble to find their opponents' trinkets. Pin quickly turns to Coiny, asking where he thinks the FreeSmart team might have hidden their van. Coiny spots the van poorly hidden behind a tree and points it out to Pin. Without hesitation, the contestants agree to tag it out.
Meanwhile, Pencil quickly formulates a plan. She grabs the van and throws it at Book, who uses a tennis racket from her pages to hit it back. The back-and-forth continues for a while, but the tension grows as Book and Pencil decide it’s time to break away and put some distance between themselves and the others. Book, Pencil, and Needle then jump into the van and drive away, leaving the rest of the teams behind.
Coiny raises his concerns about Needle joining FreeSmart, but Pin assures him that Needle is probably just trying to sabotage their efforts. Coiny, reluctantly agreeing with Pin’s assessment, suggests they focus on tracking down one of the other teams instead. Pin, confident in her plan, proposes going after Tennis Ball’s tall obelisk, noting that it shouldn’t be too hard to find. She ponders aloud where Tennis Ball might have hidden it, intrigued by the challenge ahead.
Meanwhile, Fries starts pulling piles of dirt from the ground. He looks to Coiny after each pile and asks if that’s his dirt cake, only for Coiny to shake his head each time. Coiny tells Fries that he’s going to have to taste each one to figure it out. Coiny goes on to boast that his special dirt cake will taste indescribably better than all the others before he walks away.
Pin and Coiny spot the FreeSmart van speeding off in the distance, and Coiny starts to doubt whether Needle is actually going to sabotage FreeSmart. Pin reassures him, telling him they need to catch up to that van. She tells Coiny to get on her and he complies. Pin activates her rockets, and they take off at high speed, quickly closing the gap between them and the van.
The chase continues through various venues, with Coiny encouraging Pin to keep going as they gain ground. Pin, determined, propells her rockets even faster. They close in on the van, and Coiny is now inches away from tagging it, but they still need a little more speed to get close enough.
The FreeSmart van suddenly stops at a gas station to refuel, and Coiny is seen directly drinking gasoline from the fuel pump until the FreeSmarters quickly speed off once again. Coiny and Pin are undeterred, however, and they immediately follow, determined not to let the van get away again.
As the chase continues, the FreeSmart van, still ahead, veers into the desert, with Pin and Coiny hot on its tail. However, they are abruptly halted by an immense load of corn blocking their path. As they emerge from the cornfield, Coiny spots the van driving away. To his surprise, he realizes that the FreeSmarters have left Needle behind.
Pin asks where Book and Pencil have gone. Needle, feeling left eager to show that she’s still part of the action, tells them that the two of them went to the oasis. Coiny, in disbelief, calls Needle a terrible FreeSmart member and extends his hand for a high five. Needle, however, responds by slapping him instead, leaving Coiny perplexed.
The trio set off in search of Pencil and Book when Needle suddenly hears Pencil calling her name. Eager to find her, Needle quickly follows the voice, with Coiny and Pin trailing behind. They arrive, and Pin, frustrated, demands to know where the van went. Pencil, clearly amused, refuses to tell them. Needle, however, quickly shouts that the van is in the lake. Coiny thanks her before diving straight into the water, hoping to tag the van and gain an advantage.
Underwater, Coiny relentlessly chases after the FreeSmart van, his determination unwavering. The van resurfaces, leading them into a dark cave. Emerging from the water, Coiny sprints after the vehicle, his eyes fixed on his target. Inside the van, Book struggles, panicking as she fumbles to drive. Reacting impulsively, she reverses the van, slamming Coiny into a cave wall. She quickly speeds off, leaving Coiny behind, though he survives the impact and resumes the pursuit.
Coiny continues his chase but eventually loses sight of the van. As he stumbles through the cave, his movements inadvertently slice a hole through Fries, who had been searching nearby. Startled, Coiny apologizes and notices Fries glowing faintly. Oblivious to the glow, Fries confidently brushes it off, attributing no importance to his appearance and wearing a proud smile.
Confused, Coiny questions Fries' presence in the cave. Fries explains he’s searching for the dirt cake, prompting Coiny to express disbelief at the idea of hiding it there. He quips that Fries’ “potatoey brain” must have been influenced by the glowing gunk.
As Coiny wonders aloud how to escape the cave, a chilling presence looms: Evil Leafy appears silently beside them. Coiny darts in frantic circles around Fries, attempting to avoid the threat, while Fries remains unfazed and motionless. Eventually, Fries halts Coiny’s frantic movements, urging him to show some "respect to the wicked and vile." He then casually introduces Evil Leafy as his "best friend" and embraces her. In an instant, Evil Leafy teleports inside Fries, transforming him ominously as a sinister red glow overtakes his form. This leaves Coiny confused and a little alarmed.
Coiny climbs up through a hole, returning to the grasslands where his dirt cake lies in plain view. Nearby, he notices Pin and Needle chasing Tennis Ball with unwavering determination. Curious, Coiny inquires about the commotion. Pin quickly directs him to stop Tennis Ball, and as Tennis Ball nears, Coiny instinctively trips him, sending him tumbling back into the hole. Pin, frustrated, clarifies that she wanted him caught, not tripped. Coiny sheepishly apologizes.
Spotting his dirt cake, Coiny grabs it and hands it to Needle, instructing her to guard it closely. Needle confidently promises to keep it safe. However, moments later, Tennis Ball re-emerges from the hole, teetering on its edge. As he falls back in, he pulls Needle down with him, along with the dirt cake. In the cave below, Fries manages to tag the dirt cake, officially putting W.O.A.H. Bunch up for elimination. Tennis Ball and Fries soon surface from the hole; leaving only Tennis Ball, Nickel, and Fries still in contention for the challenge.
"Needle, take our trinket, don't let anyone tag it!"
Curious about Tennis Ball’s own trinket, Coiny questions its location. Tennis Ball points to a tall obelisk partially obscured behind a tree. The obelisk is encased in a protective layer designed to prevent others from tagging it, solidifying its security in the game.
Later, it’s revealed that Nickel’s trinket was actually taped to Tennis Ball’s back all along. Realizing he can’t reach it, Tennis Ball pleads with Fries to tag it for him. However, just as Fries is about to touch the trinket, Balloony abruptly announces that Fries is out of the game. Before anyone can react, Fries is suddenly struck by a bolt of lightning.
Coiny, Pin, and Tennis Ball look around in confusion, trying to determine the source of the lightning. Their questions are answered when Nickel appears, dramatically arriving with Fries' trinket in hand. He’s perched atop a cluster of balloons and proudly declares that he finally managed to tag Fries’ trinket. Nickel explains that he harnessed the power of the storm to help him, showcasing his newfound control over the balloons to generate electrical attacks.
Without hesitation, Nickel begins firing bolts of electricity at the remaining players. Coiny and Tennis Ball scatter in panic, dodging the relentless strikes. Tennis Ball, visibly distressed, asks what they should do. Coiny, staying composed, tells him to tag Nickel out before Nickel can do the same to them. Before their plan can be executed, a sudden lightning bolt arcs toward Coiny, striking him directly. With a flash of light, a bolt of lightning arcs down, striking Coiny and leaving him lifeless on the ground.
In "Start the Shift", Coiny is recovered by Tennis Ball. Shortly after, Balloony arrives, ready to begin the next Cake at Stake. However, his appearance is met with open criticism, with Pencil calling him annoying. Coiny agrees, venting frustration about the LOLers' hosting, a sentiment quickly echoed by the other contestants. Sensing a shared disdain for Balloony, the BFDIA contestants devise a plan to remove him.
Their strategy involves recovering Spongy and launching him high into the air. As Spongy descends, Balloony, realizing the danger, tries to evade the impending crash. Unfortunately, Spongy lands directly on the LOL's fan, shredding him to pieces. Dismayed and feeling unwelcome, Balloony makes a phone call, requesting a replacement. With a solemn demeanor, he departs, taking the rest of the LOLers with him and marking the end of their hosting tenure.
As Balloony leaves, Coiny questions who he had called. Moments later, the new host is revealed to be Firey, accompanied by the other eliminated contestants. Upon seeing him, Coiny silently walks over and slaps Firey, his actions speaking volumes without a single word. The competition resumes, and W.O.A.H. Bunch—Coiny, Bomby, Nickel, and Pin—reunites. However, unlike the heartfelt reunions of other teams, theirs is marked by awkward silence. The atmosphere is heavy with sidelong glances and unspoken words, with none of the members expressing genuine happiness about being brought back together.
The new hosts kick off the next Cake at Stake, where Coiny and Tennis Ball are quickly declared the first ones safe with 8,414 and 6,879 dislikes, respectively. Both cheer in relief, and Coiny attempts to high-five Tennis Ball in celebration. However, his excitement results in an accidental slap to Tennis Ball's face, prompting Tennis Ball to kick him in retaliation. Despite the mishap, both are rewarded with a slice of cake.
After Cake at Stake, the remaining contestants transition into the team-switching phase, signaling the start of the final seven. Coiny celebrates the milestone, proudly noting that W.O.A.H. Bunch is still going strong. He high-fives Pin and Needle, and Book joins in, high-fiving Needle as well. Book asks if FreeSmart is still up and running, but before Needle can respond, Coiny laughs at the notion. Pin chimes in, dismissing FreeSmart as practically defunct without Pencil's leadership. Book, however, firmly disagrees, insisting that FreeSmart isn’t dead.
Caught in the middle, Needle hesitates, suggesting she could continue playing for both teams—FreeSmart and W.O.A.H. Bunch. Coiny and Pin immediately protest, urging her to pick a side. Needle pauses, weighing her options. Coiny encourages her to stick with W.O.A.H. Bunch, pointing out that the votes show she’s more popular as a W.O.A.H. Buncher. He emphasizes the bond they share, especially with him and Pin. Book, on the other hand, argues that Needle truly thrived on FreeSmart and reminds her of their shared history as alternates. She insists that they can rebuild FreeSmart together.
Coiny and Book both tug at Needle’s arms, both desperate to sway her to their side. Pin, determined not to lose her teammate, confronts Book, declaring she won’t let her take Needle away from W.O.A.H. Bunch again. The argument quickly spirals into a full-blown fight, with voices raised and accusations flying back and forth over who deserves to have Needle on their team.
Overwhelmed by the pressure and chaos, Needle finally snaps, shouting at everyone to stop. She pulls herself free from their grasp, silencing the group with a sharp glare. Taking a deep breath, Needle shocks everyone by declaring that she’ll team up with Fries instead. The announcement leaves the group stunned, their earlier determination replaced with visible disappointment. Despite their protests, Needle's decision is firm and unyielding. With that, the team-switching phase comes to a close, and Coiny remains on W.O.A.H. Bunch, alongside Pin.
The wheel determining the next challenge lands on "Be your truest self." Confused, Coiny asks what that means, and Golf Ball steps in to explain. The challenge requires contestants to restore their original appearances, as many have undergone significant changes throughout the competition. A scanner will evaluate each contestant's appearance, and for a team to be declared safe, all its members must pass the scanner's approval.
With the instructions clear, the contest begins. Coiny, confident in his unaltered state, proclaims that this challenge will be a breeze. He quickly licks the cake off himself and strides onto the platform. As the scanner evaluates him, a green light flashes, signifying approval. Coiny cheers, proud of his unchanged appearance. However, for W.O.A.H. Bunch to be declared safe, Pin still needs to pass the scanner’s approval.
Later, Fries accidentally kills Needle with a large block, but as the block lands, it crushes Fries as well. Coiny asks for clarification that they’re not going to recover them, while Pin questions what they should do next. Coiny, confused, insists that he's perfect, but Pin points out that she's not, due to lacking her limbs. Coiny tells her not to talk down about herself, but Pin, frustrated, explains that she’s supposed to have her limbs back to be her truest self and asks how they're supposed to fix that. Coiny suggests they don't necessarily need to restore her limbs but could make it appear as though she has them. Pin likes the idea but asks how they can pull it off, though Coiny admits he doesn’t have a plan. Pin sarcastically thanks him for the suggestion.
Later, Coiny removes Pin's treads and battery. However, Pin still needs her limbs to pass the scanner. She says she can't move without her mech suit, to which Coiny reassures her that it's fine. But before he can finish his thought, Tennis Ball’s washcloth hits Pin, sending her off a cliff. Coiny angrily calls Tennis Ball a villain and rushes to save Pin. He quickly straps Pin’s treads to his own feet and rides down the side of the cliff.
As Coiny reaches the bottom of the cliff, he braces to catch Pin, but she lands directly on top of him. Pin comments on the soft landing before asking where they are. Coiny replies that they're at the bottom of a cliff. Pin then notices a mine in the distance, with a large sign reading "Yoylite Mines". She asks him what that is, and Coiny recognizes the word "Yoylite" as the "super powerful rock thing" Tennis Ball has been talking about. He surmises that, since yoylite is so powerful, it might somehow help restore Pin’s limbs. Pin asks if he really thinks that’s possible, and Coiny admits that he has no idea but adds that it's worth a shot, noting that there’s probably a lot of Yoylite inside the mine.
Once they enter, Coiny asks if Pin can see anything but due to the mines being dark, she couldn’t spot a single thing. Coiny gets frustrated and regrets not bringing a light source. But with the help of one of Pin’s rockets, he manages to light it up so they could explore what was there. He then finds a mine cart full of yoylite. He grabs the stash while Pin questions him, asking if the stash was the yoylite they were trying to find. He answers a yes eagerly and wants to explore more. So he points the rocket forward, but pauses to find that Evil Leafy was in front of them. He kicks the mine cart to try and knock her over, but she teleports in front of them and him and Pin both scream and were running towards the exit, but Coiny trips, making the rocket fly to the top of the entrance, causing the rocket to veer off and collide with the mine entrance, triggering an explosion that results in a massive rockfall, sealing the way out.
Panicked, Pin accuses Coiny of dooming them with no way to escape. Coiny insists there’s still a solution. Using Pin's remaining rocket, he propels them upward, with Pin acting as a drill to tunnel through the dirt. After some effort, they resurface at ground level, startling Book and Needle with their sudden appearance. Coiny drops the Yoylite during the climb, and it lands in Fries' fries, injuring him.
Coiny greets the others, but notices they look exactly the same as they did at the start of the challenge, pointing out their lack of progress. Book swiftly picks up Fries and heads toward the superstore, explaining that she needs him for a deal with the shopkeepers. Alarmed, Coiny and Pin chase after her, shouting that they need Fries because he has their Yoylite. Book reaches the store and hands Fries to Soda as part of her deal. Moments later, Coiny arrives and snatches Fries away, ignoring Lemonade's protests about being robbed. Just as Coiny exits the store, Needle intercepts, grabbing Fries and sprinting off with him.
Coiny and Pin return to the group, overhearing Golf Ball scolding them for mishandling the Yoylite. Coiny questions if there’s truly no more yoylite, as they could have used it to restore Pin’s limbs. Golf Ball, perplexed, asks why Coiny believed that yoylite could generate new limbs. Pin then asks Golf Ball for an alternative solution to restore her limbs.
At that moment, Coiny devises an idea. He removes Pin’s treads and battery, then steps onto the platform while holding her. As the scanner evaluates Pin, Coiny positions his own limbs to act as replacements for hers, hoping the scanner will approve this workaround. After the evaluation concludes, the scanner accepts Pin. She's shocked that the plan actually worked, while Coiny beams with pride, thrilled his idea was successful. As a result, both Pin and Coiny are declared safe for completing the challenge first, leaving the other teams vulnerable and up for elimination.
In "Airplanes in the Night Sky", Coiny and Pin are declared safe at Cake at Stake, having won immunity in the previous episode. Additionally, Tennis Ball is revealed to have received the most likes and is awarded the Disbandment Token, granting him the power to permanently dissolve any team. After Cake at Stake, Tennis Ball chooses to disband W.O.A.H. Bunch, causing their team logo to crumble into ash and scatter to the ground. As he walks away, Coiny angrily shakes his fist at him. Pin sighs, acknowledging that this is the end of the Bunch, but Coiny tells her, “May the best player win", before blowing a raspberry at her.
For the next challenge, the WTFers lead the remaining contestants to a new location. Coiny spins the wheel to determine the challenge, which lands on "Light Up the Sky". Confused, he asks what it means, prompting Gelatin to explain: Contestants must light up the sky using their assigned beacons by reaching the top of three satellite towers and activating them. The first contestant to have all three of their beacons lit at the same time will win immunity.
With that, the challenge begins, and Coiny deliberately trips over Book, setting off a domino effect that knocks everyone else down. Seizing the opportunity, Coiny dashes toward the lighthouse and sprints up the stairs, reaching the top first. He quickly activates his beacon before rushing back down the stairs. On his way down, Coiny shoves Tennis Ball down the stairs, watching as he tumbles.
As Pin ascends the stairs, she warns Coiny not to trip her, and Coiny assures her he wasn't planning to. He then begins climbing the ladder, noticing Needle sliding toward him. He leans forward just in time, letting Needle speed past without colliding. Coiny continues climbing, reaching the top of the tower. He announces over the dispatch that he's on track to winning immunity, then turns on his second beacon. Now, Coiny just needs one more to win.
Book arrives shortly after, declaring that she's also in it to win it. Coiny, however, clarifies that he's not talking to anyone in particular. Book chuckles, acknowledging that she knows, but adds that it's still nice to hear. Coiny then announces that he'd like to make an update on Book's status, when suddenly, Tennis Ball crashes into Book, knocking her off the radio tower. Coiny casually remarks that she's doing terribly before greeting Tennis Ball and telling him he's starting to like this vicious, violent side of him.
Tennis Ball, slightly confused, asks where he is. Coiny responds that he's on top of the radio tower. Tennis Ball is relieved, saying he wasn't sure how he was going to climb all those ladders. He then turns on his second beacon, declaring that he's now in the lead. Coiny corrects him, stating that they're actually tied for the lead.
Coiny quickly races down the ladder, determined to stay ahead. He rushes over to the final tower and calls out to Needle, asking her to bring the elevator down. Needle, without hesitation, complies, and Coiny thanks her, adding that he's glad she's still looking out for the W.O.A.H. Bunch. Needle looks confused, so Coiny explains that he's about to win since he's on track to activating his third beacon, and if one of them wins, they all win.
"You know, cause I'm about to win. Once I get to my third beacon."
Coiny assures her that everyone will appreciate her act of sacrifice before stepping into the elevator. However, Needle rolls Coiny away upon hearing the mention of "sacrifice", then speeds off in the opposite direction, leaving him stunned. Later, Coiny waits impatiently for the elevator to return, when suddenly, Fries arrives and asks where the elevator is. Coiny, still annoyed, tells him he has to wait for it to come back down. Just then, Pin takes advantage of the chaos and turns off everyone's beacons except for her own. The scene quickly transitions into a fast-paced montage of Coiny and the other contestants scrambling from tower to tower, frantically flipping each other's levers on and off in a fierce, chaotic battle to keep their own beacons lit.
The scene cuts to Coiny finally stepping into the elevator, but just as the doors begin to close, Fries rushes in and wedges his arm to hold the doors open. The two engage in a chaotic struggle as the elevator ascends, each trying to outmaneuver the other. The fight continues as the elevator reaches the top, but their scuffle is suddenly interrupted by Book, who soars past them in a paper airplane. She shouts that she might actually win, causing Coiny and Fries to pause and exchange glances.
Seeing an opportunity, they both agree to sabotage Book's chances. Coiny snatches one of Fries' fries and hurls it at Book's radio tower beacon switch, effectively turning it off. With that done, Coiny makes a run for the beacon switches, but Fries blocks his path. In retaliation, Coiny rips a support beam from the roof and charges at Fries, who is armed with one of his fries. The two charge at each other, but miss, leaving Coiny to casually suggest they try again. However, before Coiny can make his move, the roof above them collapses, crushing Fries under the weight of the broken support beam that Coiny had torn off. Coiny lets out a triumphant cheer before swiftly turning off Fries' beacon and switching his own on.
As Coiny dashes toward the watchtower, he glances back and realizes someone has turned another one of his beacons on. This means he only has one more beacon to light, so he pushes himself to run even faster. However, when he arrives at the tower, he discovers that Pin has died. He looks around, asking if anyone is going to recover her, but the others refuse, leaving him with the decision of what to do next.
Coiny stares at Pin's lifeless body for a moment, then looks back at the watchtower, conflicted. After a brief pause, he makes up his mind and decides to recover her himself. He returns back to Yoyleland and uses the Recovery Center to bring Pin back to life, urging her to return to the challenge quickly. As soon as Pin is recovered, Coiny hops onto her back, and she jets toward the towers.
Upon arrival, Coiny wonders if there's still enough time for him to get his third beacon before someone else catches up to his other ones. But before he can make his move, Tennis Ball suddenly turns off Coiny's beacon. Pin tells Coiny that if he wanted to win, he shouldn't have bothered to recover her. Coiny is left confused, unsure of what to make of her statement.
Coiny, Pin, and Fries climb up the watchtower, where Needle urgently tells them to shut off Tennis Ball's beacon. Without hesitation, Coiny complies, but as soon as he flips the switch, he gets electrocuted. Moments before, Tennis Ball had wrapped wires around Nickel's chunk and tied it to the beacon switches. Tennis Ball smirks, telling Coiny that he got what he deserved for underestimating his clever brain. He boasts that with his setup, Coiny has no way to interfere with him from the tower. In response, Coiny casually misaligns Tennis Ball’s beacon signal.
Tennis Ball shouts in protest, but Coiny simply turns to the others and asks what they’re supposed to do about their own levers now, since Tennis Ball’s trick prevented them from switching them back on. Without hesitation, Pin leaps into action. Using her mech suit, she sends out a powerful electrical signal before jumping onto the levers, flipping all of them up at once. Coiny congratulates Pin on her efforts, but Pin, visibly annoyed, groans that she only meant to flip her own switch.
Coiny urges Pin to move quickly as they ride down the elevator and race toward the final watchtower. As they approach, he tells her that they need to start climbing, and Pin responds that she was already aware. However, just as they begin their ascent, Fries fires his drill gun at the tower, slicing through the base and causing it to collapse. Coiny calls the impact insane before asking Pin if she's okay. However, Pin rushes forward without hesitation, focused solely on the finish line. Coiny, struggling to keep up, calls after her.
As the remaining contestants scramble up the unstable structure, Tennis Ball collides with Needle, sending both tumbling downward. Pin skillfully leaps over them, avoiding the crash, but Coiny gets caught in their fall, and the three dangle precariously from the tower’s side. Struggling to maintain his grip, Coiny reaches out to Pin for help. Pin shifts her attention to Book, who is making a final dash toward the beacon, before slowly backing away without a word.
Coiny, confused by her hesitation, pleads with her not to abandon him, reminding her of everything he did for her: recovering her during the challenge, restoring her face, and supporting her throughout. Before he can say more, Fries stomps on his hand, forcing him to lose his grip. As he plummets toward the ground, he desperately shouts that he dug to the center of the earth for her, just before crash-landing.
Meanwhile, Pin methodically sabotages the remaining contestants, one by one. Eventually, she reaches the final beacon and activates it, bathing the sky in a scarlet glow to signal her victory. As a result, all other contestants, including Coiny, are placed up for elimination.
In "Welcome Back", he entered the Grotato Farm, and loudly exclaimed that the Grotatoes were going to taste delicious, causing the city to shake a bit. He tried to taste one of them, but Fries told him to be patient. He took a deep breath and jokingly said that it was "a deep-fried breath." Later, he asks how Pin's new limbs feel after 6 months. She says they're just a little tingly but getting better.
Coiny in IDFB
Tennis Ball and Golf Ball then arrive with a Wall Teleporter, and Coiny says that it was the "most awesome thing" he had ever seen, but he didn't know what it was. After a some discussing, they realize they can free contestants from the LOL. They all make their way to the LOL, and Coiny suggests releasing Snowball, which made Golf Ball mad. In the stinger ending, Coiny has some boiling frying oil so that they can make deep fried breaths. Coiny does three of them offscreen while Fries begs for him to stop.
Battle for BFDI[]
Coiny in Battle for BFDI
In "Getting Teardrop to Talk", Pin's blueberry seeds land next to Coiny and he sets a challenge for who can throw them into a distant pot in Cloudy's Pile of Stuff. Snowball and Firey try unsuccessfully before Taco manages to do it. Firey and Coiny cheer shortly before Pin asks where her seeds are, and the two start nervously sweating.
Later after Four arrives and deforms Pin, Coiny begs him to bring her back, fluttering his arms. The problem is soon resolved. Coiny becomes part of The Losers. In the challenge, he gets angry at Pin for suggesting that they focus on the contest over Loser.
In "Four Goes Too Far", Loser put everyone in his team under one of X's baskets, supposedly saving the team from the Twinkle. Later, Pin worries about the team being so Loser-centric. Coiny comforted her, recalling past experiences from W.O.A.H. Bunch, the team which both captained in BFDIA. He reassures that everything will okay, which she says really means a lot. He then invites her ogle to Loser with the rest of the team and she accepts. At one point, Needle asks who has the twinkle and Firey guesses Black Hole. Coiny angrily points out that Black Hole doesn't have eyes so he can't get the twinkle and slaps him. His team ended up losing after Bell busted a hole in the basket, causing Clock to get the twinkle.
In "The Liar Ball You Don't Want", Coiny was the second safe with 526 votes. When he received his cake, which happened to be a popper, Pin noted that it was not cake. Donut replied that they were topped with a grain of sugar. Coiny then said he was "gonna find it", and began licking his popper ravenously. He and the rest of his team gasp when Loser is revealed to be eliminated.
In "Questions Answered", Pin gives her team a motivational speech about how they can win the challenge even without Loser present. Coiny backs her up by saying that she is right.
In "This Episode Is About Basketball", Coiny made a dish of dirt for Marker. When presenting the dish, he matched the pose of Four raising his hand and started the intro. During the challenge, after seeing Firey fail to throw a ball, Coiny picks it up and throws it. His throw misses and hits Cloudy's window. He also accidentally throws balls at a bunch of recommended characters.
In "Enter The Exit", Coiny says Pin should squirt the liquid out into the shape of Four because she was great at making cakes. When Pin says she can't because she's afraid of messing up, Coiny holds her hand and assures her that she'll do a great job.
In "Get to the Top in 500 Steps", Coiny welcomes Leafy to the team, saying it's been a while since they've talked. When selecting the runners, Coiny asks why Firey is doing nothing. He simply replies that he's doing nothing and asks if there's a reason for him to do anything else. This annoys Coiny but he instead decides to tell him Needle will be running up the stairs. Firey protests by saying that he was a fast runner, confusing Coiny as he remembered Firey saying that he was slow. Firey corrects him and says it was Coiny who said he was slow, which he admits is true. But Coiny disregards this since Firey is scared of heights anyway.
In "What Do You Think of Roleplay?", Coiny notices that Needle is now CGI. When Needle says that it's because of the Photo Cake from Leafy, Coiny asks her if this is true.
In "Return of the Rocket Ship", Book tells Ice Cube that it's no longer BFDIA. In response, Coiny shouts from the background that he knows that. When Gaty asks if he has something he wants to talk about, he shouts "No!" and runs away. Later, during the challenge, Coiny interrupts Eggy and Cake's argument, asking why they are yelling.
In "Don't Dig Straight Down", Coiny and Cake run into Golf Ball's Underground Factory for shelter from the lava after realizing that their entire team is probably dead. They bump into Naily and Woody, who are running up the stairs because of the lava chasing them from below. With no other way to escape, Woody and Naily spot a deprecated garbage chute. Coiny has the others throw him towards it since the opening was boarded up. He manages to unloosen its screws, only to end up falling into the lava afterward.
In "The Four is Lava", Coiny is seen with Naily when the lava is drained, surprised to realize they aren't dead. Later, he is seen running with Naily and Flower. He spots X, thinking the other contestants must be close. Flower tells him she will beat him there. Coiny thinks that this is not a contest, but when Flower says otherwise, he kicks Naily out of the way. Needle then grabs him and takes him quickly to Four, making his team safe.
Coiny is later seen in the stinger of the episode with his team. He approaches a saddened Leafy, who decides to stop sulking, and asks her if she wants to join the team in asking Four to recover the other dead Losers. He then realizes, with the rest of his team, that Clock had been missing.
In "The Escape from Four", Coiny, along with the rest of the contestants, investigate Four's struggles to eliminate Spongy, and then proceed to try and free the eliminated contestants. Coiny later quits BFB to become a participant on TPOT.
Battle for BFB[]
In "X Marks the Spot", Coiny suggests gluing X to the ground to stop the BFB cast from taking him. When X and Two suggest otherwise, Coiny claims that he has glue that is certified to be gentle on numeric membranes. When he tries to grab the glue, Lollipop switches it with a bucket of paint, which Coiny grabs instead, and dumps the paint on the ground. Pin places X on the paint, and Coiny claims that X will now be able to keep hosting their show. Then the Four Colored Team throws a lasso on X, pulling him away from the TPOT cast.
Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two[]
Coiny in Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two
In "You Know Those Buttons Don't Do Anything, Right?", Coiny, with Pin and Needle, join Donut's team, wanting to bring W.O.A.H. Bunch back. Coiny suggests calling the team W.O.A.H. Bunch again but Gaty thinks the name is stupid, sparking a brief argument on the team name. During the challenge, Coiny uses Pin to climb up the building, which leads the other Team8s to use the sharp members to climb up, which led to his team being the third team safe.
In "The Worst Day of Black Hole's Life", Coiny is first seen walking to the elevator before Two starts the intro. During the contest, Coiny suggests that his team should glue their blocks together. Pin, however, isn't okay with this strategy and she feels that it might be cheating. Coiny is confused as to where this side of Pin came from since she was fine with them taking the easy way out in challenges in BFDIA. Pin refutes, saying that their time on BFDIA sucked and leaves to go ask Two if using glue is allowed. The glue ends up benefitting the team as they can make the stack as tall as they want and it didn't fall apart whenever Eraser knocked into it. Pin and Gaty arrive back to stop their team's cheating, but Gaty is surprised at how tall their stack is. With no objections from Two and the rest of the team being okay with their strategy, Coiny asks Pin if she's ready to join them again, and Pin reluctantly obliges. Later, Bell attempts to knock their stack over but gets stuck to it, and begins carrying the stack everywhere as Coiny and the rest of the team chase her to get it back. Needle manages to return their stack to their podium. The Team8s are safe with the largest stack, which gets them a token from Two. Coiny says it looks just like him, until Gaty points out that he's orange, making Coiny frown.
In "Getting Puffball To Think About Rollercoasters", Coiny overhears The Strongest Team on Earth. talking about food and decides that their attraction should be a restaurant. Pin considers that cheating since it was another team's idea and Coiny points out that they aren't using it. Later, Coiny uses Saw to carve some tables and chairs out of blocks. The team ends up forgetting to have a dish ready so Coiny improvises by having Barf Bag as the main course. Unfortunately, Coiny's team has their restaurant obliterated by Eraser and they get a 0/10 score. Both Team8s and The S! are up for elimination.
In "Gardening Zero", Coiny is the second contestant safe at his team's Cake at Stake, with 4,290 votes. After Saw's elimination, Coiny suggests that they use the Funny Plant as a shrine to remember her memory. However, the plant is immediately killed after it loses all three of its lives. Coiny's team is sent to Yoyleland, which has a sufficient amount of requirements to naturally nurture a Funny Plant.
In "Fishes and Dishes", Coiny is first shown serving a plate of dirt to a Funny Plant. During the challenge, he pulls out a phone and presents the Stuff For Yourself online store to his team. He tries to say what they need to order, but keeps getting interrupted by his teammates when they order items to help in the challenge. Coiny eventually says that what they need is the world's strongest magnet to pull the plates from the bottom of the canal. His team doesn't listen as they want to order more stuff and reach for his phone.
Due to being distracted, Coiny orders the magnet, but has it delivered to Yellow Face's Warehouse. After boarding "The Slowest Train Ever", which is changed to "The Fastest Train Ever", Coiny's team makes it to the warehouse. Gaty and Pin find a package for Coiny, but it has a world ending bomb inside, Coiny sheepishly shoves it aside and pulls out another package with the magnet. The magnet has a unique feature that allows the user to select what it attracts. Needle tells him to set the magnet to magnify the train and he does so. Needle then tosses him in front of the train, causing Coiny to fly in the air while the magnet holds him in place, while also pulling the train back to the competition. His team makes it back just in time for Coiny to swipe the last plate from Eraser with the magnet so that he could hand it to Two, making his team safe.
In "The Great Goikian Bake-Off", Coiny is first seen dressed as a sandwich in an attempt to get some food from Four, which fails. Later during the challenge, Coiny suggests that the team uses his sandwich costume to trap Two, in order to make them dinner. Coiny's first attempt to capture Two included using Pin to cut a rope to a cage that would fall on Two (They were able to walk out between the bars). Next, Coiny uses the World's Strongest Magnet on the Moon to crush Two, but the Moon rolled above Two and crushed Coiny instead. After Bottle ruined the team's final plan, Coiny goes back to suggesting that they should use his sandwich prop as dinner. When it was time for Two to rate all the meals, they end up between Coiny's bread slices. Two seemed amused by the idea of a "Two Meal", calling it "Delightful". Team8s was rated the highest out of any other team in the challenge, earning a 10/10. Later in the stinger, Coiny is zapped by X in a attempt to steal some food from the hotel.
In "The Seven Wonders of Goiky", for the challenge, Coiny's team is tasked with restoring the Balance Beam. Coiny and Pin challenge each other to see who can stay on the beam longer. Pin starts throwing items at Coiny to make him fall off. Coiny catches a mirror she threw and the two of them tug on it so much it extends all the way to the end of the balance beam. Coiny's team aligns the broken half of the mirror. Howber, the mirror breaks when Pin gets excited and shakes Coiny too much. They solve the problem with some wires Just Not gave them in trade for the mirror.
Donut is assigned to be crushed and mangled for the balance beam to be fixed. Coiny, Pin, and Gaty pull on one side of the balance beam, and Needle and Barf Bag do the other side. Donut is crushed by the balance beam and his cherry filling fixes the balance beam. Two is called to test the beam and loves it so much that Coiny's team is safe and places 2nd.
In "Balancing P.A.C.T.", Coiny covers his ears after Donut screams for losing his arms. Later in the challenge, Donut rolls across the balance beam, and Coiny says to Barf Bag that she can volunteer with her newfound strength to propel someone to the other side to get Donut. Coiny then mimics Pin and calls her heroic. Pin wonders if she said that, but she says it checks out since she is heroic, and she is thrown across the balance beam by Barf Bag. Later, Coiny gets into a fight on the beam with Pen, Tennis Ball, and Eraser. Tennis Ball hits Coiny with Pen and he falls off the balance beam. Coiny’s team loses and is up for elimination.
In "Outbreak At Stake", Coiny and his team take refuge in the hotel from the zombies outside. When Coiny is in the bottom four, he worries since one of his friends are getting eliminated, but Pin tells him that they'll be fine, until Barf Bag and Pin are next safe, leaving Coiny and Needle in the bottom two, with the two of the them panicking. Needle is revealed to be safe by a 20 vote difference with 4,890 votes, while Coiny is out with 4,870 votes.
Pin is upset about Coiny's elimination, and says she's sorry to him. Coiny says that it's fine and that he's just letting Anchor in, but Pin says that it’s not just about the door, but that he's out of the game, and that she is sorry and wanted to go further with him. She asks how she'll do this without him. Barf Bag then breaks into the hotel and bites Coiny, infecting him.
Coiny chases Pin, Needle, and Donut down into the sewers of the hotel, with Pin wanting to save Coiny, but Needle protests and says that Coiny is not himself right now. Pin sees Coiny again when she’s above the canal trying to get out. Pin says that she's so sorry that he got out, and that she doesn't know if she can figure this out alone. Coiny jumps at Pin, growling, but Pin grabs him, and says that Needle was right when she said that he wasn’t himself. She then says that she can figure this out, and uses Coiny to get out of the canal, killing him in the process.
In "Category One", Coiny appears briefly on the debut screen.
In "Bottle For Dream Island", Coiny appears in the beginning of the episode in Pin's room, helping her set up. Teardrop runs in and throws him out of the room so he can help all the other eliminated contestants bust down the exit door.
Coiny is one of many characters who is seen with a phone, the others are Leafy, Announcer, Balloony, Flower, Two, Fanny, Pillow, Barf Bag, Fries, and more.
Additionally, he is also one of five characters with a smartphone, with the others being Pen, Basketball, Price Tag, and Winner.
Coiny was the only contestant to be eliminated during the team switching phase who actually had the most votes from the viewers.
Coiny was the only male contestant that got eliminated in the three-team stage of BFDI.
Coiny is the only male contestant to be dropped in the Tiny Loser Chamber by a platform, the others being Ice Cube (in "Hurtful!"), Golf Ball, and Teardrop, all of which are females.
Coiny is the lowest ranking male in BFDI to qualify for BFDIA.
BFDIA[]
Coiny came in 10th place out of the original contestants in Season 2 voting.
Coiny, Flower, Snowball, Fanny, & Lightning are the only contestants to be up for elimination at the start of multiple seasons. In Coiny's case, he was up for elimination in the firstepisodes of both BFDI & BFDIA.
Coiny is the only one who had this happen before BFB. He is also the only one who was never on iance.
Coiny & Snowball are the only ones who have gone at least one season without losing in the first episode.
Coiny was the first contestant to win a prize in BFDIA.
Coiny was the first contestant to get a slice of cake in BFDIA.
Coiny, Ice Cube, Bomby, Ruby, and Fries are currently the only BFDIA contestants who received the most and least likes in different Cake at Stakes.
In "Zeeky Boogy Doog", Coiny became the first contestant to survive an elimination despite receiving the least likes on his team.
After Donut's elimination, up to team swaps in "Zeeky Boogy Doog", Coiny was the only remaining male character on W.O.A.H. Bunch.
Coiny has the third least amount of votes in BFB at 526. The only contestants with less than him are Tennis Ball and Pin at 500 and 305 votes respectively.
BFB 1 marked the first time where Coiny wasn't on the team that lost first.
Coiny is one of the six contestants in the series to technically have the same ranking twice as he placed 16th in BFDI and tied for the same rank in BFB. The others are Pin, Needle, Golf Ball, Donut, and Puffball.
Spongy also counts if Profily's rank in BFB is dismissed.
With Firey being absent in TPOT, Coiny is the only male contestant with all limbs to be in all 5 seasons.
Coiny follows the same pattern as Remote in TPOT. Both went from being safe with the second most votes at their first Cake at Stake, to being eliminated at their next.
Coiny is the second Season 1 contestant eliminated in TPOT, the first being Rocky.
With Coiny eliminated in "Outbreak At Stake", he's the lowest ranking Season 1 contestant with a full set of limbs, Season 1 contestant voiced by Micheal Huang, original member of The Losers! and the lower ranking coin in TPOT.
General[]
Coiny has made the second most physical appearances episodes of any contestant, at 73, only behind Tennis Ball at 76.
Coiny often does a pose with his right hand up and his bottom lip sticking out.
He was the first contestant to slap someone (Firey) in BFDI.
In "Get in the Van", Coiny said that when he & Nickel get close to each other, "bad things" happen. When Pin made Nickel stand next to Coiny, the area around them started to blur, proving that what Coiny stated was true.
In "The Long-lost Yoyle City", it's revealed that when they get close to each other for too long, a portal that creates tons of money appears, even though this isn't really bad. (Firey Speaker Box even uses this trick to fund the show)
In "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know", this must've not been brought up yet, since Nickel & Coiny were standing right next to each other and nothing happened.
In the game Tidepool, there's a coin that looks like Coiny, named "Penny", even though Coiny isn't a penny.
This also proves that Coiny's metal material has a higher temperature than Ruby, because the lava was hot enough to melt Ruby, who has a melting of 3,400°F. This also applies to Naily.
Contrary to popular belief, the Official Character Guide confirms Coiny isn't a penny.
However, Coiny has been previously depicted, and is valued at one cent in the episode "Sweet Tooth". The term "penny" often refers to the smallest denotation of currency in many countries across the world. It's possible that Coiny is in fact a different type of coin, but is treated as a penny when considered legal tender.
Coiny made a brief appearance on Fan's Fantastic Features in the Inanimate Insanity episode "Nickel For Your Thoughts", with Michael Huang reprising his role as Coiny. It was an ironic reference since II's Nickel was talking about knockoffs.
This also makes Coiny the only BFDI contestant to be seen in Hotel OJ.
Coiny's first cameo in Inanimate Insanity
Coiny made a cameo in the the Inanimate Insanity Invitational episode, "The Show Must Go On". He also made a non-speaking cameo in the II season 1 episode "Aquatic Conflict".
Firey
Leafy • 
Firey Jr. • 
Pen
Woody • 
Loser • 
Four • 
X
Rocky • 
Coiny • 
Marker
Two • 
Pin • 
Bubble
Tennis Ball • 
Evil Leafy • 
Golf Ball • 
Flower • 
Ruby • 
Spongy
Fanny • 
One • 
Pencil • 
Teardrop • 
Grassy
Eraser
Announcer • 
Balloony • 
Book • 
Liy • 
Five • 
Six • 
Seven • 
Eight • 
Nine • 
Ten • 
Bell • 
Taco
Bomby • 
Lollipop • 
Pillow • 
Gelatin
Lightbulb • 
Nickel (Inanimate Insanity) • 
Taco (Inanimate Insanity) • 
Box