This article lists all the recommended characters that were going to be used as normal characters at some point, whether they were planned to be up for debut, planned to appear in a game, or planned to compete in BFDI Mini, but ultimately didn't and ended up going unused.
Nurse Lily[]
Nurse Lily is a recommended character that appeared in "Bowling, Now with Explosions!". She was considered as a contestant in BFDI Mini Again but she was ultimately passed on.[1]
Appearance[]
Nurse Lily is a Davidian with medium-length pink hair wearing a white nurse outfit and poorly drawn black thin rimmed circular glasses. Unlike most Davidians who hold the same pose and facial expression, Nurse Lily is seen smiling with an arm behind her back and holding a syringe with a dark yellow liquid in it.
Coverage[]
Appearances[]
- Battle for Dream Island
- "Bowling, Now with Explosions!" (recommended)
- "Return of the Hang Glider" (recommended)
- Battle for Dream Island Again
Battle for Dream Island[]
In "Bowling, Now with Explosions!", she appears during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by pinkbelossom. She appears on the bleachers watching the Cake at Stake of that episode before Announcer walls off the area in order to "keep things private". In the after credits stinger all the recommended characters in this episode are set on fire and presumably die.
In "Return of the Hang Glider", she is seen with all the other recommended characters from season 1 during the panning scene on the bleachers watching the last Cake at Stake of the season, she is grouped with all the other episode 16 recommended characters. She is part of the recommended character "Every Recommended Character" recommended by marioluigi0128 in the previous episode.
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
In "Get in the Van", she appears in the anniversary wheel that starts the episode with all the other season 1 recommended characters.
Trivia[]
- If Nurse Lily had been added to BFDI Mini Again, she would have been the third ever female Davidian after Dora and Purple Girl with Wind Hair and Angry Eyes. Instead, Your Mom would later be the third ever female Davidian in BFDI Mini, Seriously!.
Click[]
Click is a recommended character that appeared in "Hurtful!". They were considered as a contestant in BFDI Mini Again but they were ultimately passed on.[1]
Appearance[]
Click is a poorly drawn light grey plastic computer mouse with their face on the body of the mouse, slightly darker left and right buttons, an even darker scroll wheel, and a wire out their back. They have four legs and no arms.
Changes[]
BFDI 17
- They are called Mouse.
- Mouse is better drawn.
- Mouse has shading.
- Mouse's face is on their buttons.
- Mouse has a dark grey body and scroll wheel with light grey buttons.
- Mouse's wire is thick.
- Mouse has thirteen legs.
BFDI 23
- Mouse is called Click
- Click is poorly drawn.
- Click has no shading.
- Click's face is on their body.
- Click has a light grey body with darker buttons and an even darker scroll wheel.
- Click's wire is thin.
- Click has four legs.
Coverage[]
Appearances[]
- Battle for Dream Island
- "The Reveal" (recommended)
- "Hurtful!" (recommended)
- "Return of the Hang Glider" (recommended)
- Battle for Dream Island Again
Battle for Dream Island[]
In "The Reveal", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by totaldramasurvivor1. They are seen in a simple panning shot before the Cake at Stake of that episode with their name and recommender appearing in a black box at the bottom of the screen.
In "Hurtful!", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by Karan3840. They appear during the scene of Leafy and Bubble doing all the previous challenges from episode 6 to episode 21.
In "Return of the Hang Glider", they are seen with all the other recommended characters from season 1 during the panning scene on the bleachers watching the last Cake at Stake of the season, they appear in two different places being grouped with different sets of characters due to being recommended in two different episodes. They are seen with the episode 17 recommended characters and the episode 23 recommended characters. They are part of the recommended character "Every Recommended Character" recommended by marioluigi0128 in the previous episode.
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
In "Get in the Van", they appear in the anniversary wheel that starts the episode with all the other season 1 recommended characters.
Trivia[]
- If Click had been added to BFDI Mini Again, they would have been the first BFDI contestant ever to have more than two legs.
Gallery[]
Assets[]
Get Well Card for Jacknjellify[]
Get Well Card for Jacknjellify is a recommended character that appeared in "Zeeky Boogy Doog" and was the first placing recommended character for that episode. This should've meant that Get Well Card for Jacknjellify would get to appear in BFDIA 5b but since the game was never finished they never ended up appearing.
Appearance[]
Get Well Card for Jacknjellify is a rectangular white paper card with their face on the right side and a yellow box with text reading "Get well already! I want to see the episode!" on the left side.
Coverage[]
Appearances[]
- Battle for Dream Island Again
- "Zeeky Boogy Doog" (recommended)
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
In "Zeeky Boogy Doog", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by SuperMightyMichael. They appear during the scene of Pin shaking the Eiffel Tower to get some contestants down for Cake at Stake causing it to bend forwards and backwards before beginning to stab all the recommended characters, causing Get Well Card for Jackjellify to raise their arms and scream in pain.
Trivia[]
- Get Well Card for Jacknjellify was referenced in BFDIA 13 as the design used for the "Get Well Ugly" card that Needle gives to the hospitalised Flower.
- Get Well Card for Jacknjellify's concept and their text is seemingly referencing the delay BFDIA 4 had with the recommender hoping that the creators get well so that the episode can come out.
Gallery[]
Assets[]
Cake Pop[]
Cake Pop is a recommended character that first appeared in "This Episode Is About Basketball". According to Cary Huang, Cake Pop was a considered character for the BFB 16 debut voting for who could join TPOT but they were ultimately passed on.[2]
Appearance[]
Cake Pop is a vanilla cake pop on a white plastic stick with pink, blue, and yellow sprinkles on top.
Changes[]
BFDIA 9
- Cake Pop is well drawn.
- Cake Pop has no sprinkles.
- Cake Pop is pink.
- Cake Pop's head is perfectly round.
- Cake Pop's stick is white.
BFDIA 14
- Cake Pop has small circular white sprinkles.
- Cake Pop is green.
BFB 9-15
- Cake Pop has long line pink, blue, and yellow sprinkles.
- Cake Pop is white.
- Cake Pop's head is uneven.
BFB 19
- Cake Pop is poorly drawn.
- Cake Pop has no sprinkles.
- Cake Pop is purple on top and white on bottom.
BFB 28 & 30
- Cake Pop is well drawn.
- Cake Pop has long thick line blue, yellow, and red sprinkles.
- Cake Pop is brown.
- Cake Pop's stick is tan.
Coverage[]
Appearances[]
- Battle for Dream Island Again
- "Catch These Hands" (recommended)
- "PointyPointyPointy ♫" (recommended)
- Battle for BFDI
- "This Episode Is About Basketball" (recommended)
- "Return of the Rocket Ship" (recommended)
- "Don't Dig Straight Down" (recommended)
- "The Four is Lava" (recommended)
- Battle for BFB
- "How Loe Can You Grow?" (recommended)
- "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning" (recommended)
- "Chapter Complete" (recommended)
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
In "Catch These Hands", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by Ridicolous_Objects. They are seen while FreeSmart are running down a hill and guessing each others gestures in the trash compactors.
In "PointyPointyPointy ♫", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by Cheulo2. They are seen in the audience for that episodes Cake at Stake and later when Orange kills Pan Flute and throws Pan Flute's pipes to the audience, Cake Pop grabs one of them while cheering and starts using the pipe to play a jovial tune while Orange dances.
Battle for BFDI[]
In "This Episode Is About Basketball", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by Space W. In that scene they are hit by one of the balls, an orange ball specifically, that Coiny throws causing them to frown.
In "Return of the Rocket Ship", they appear in three different groups of recommended characters for that episode being recommended by Space W. They first appear with the first batch in a panning shot leading to the Cake at Stake place for that episode. Like all other characters in this shot Cake Pop is affected by the recommended character Check-it Eyebrows recommended by That B D which causes Cake Pop to have two right facing eyebrows as their facial expression. Four uses these characters to advertise the Jacknjellify Patreon to recommend future characters as well as teasing a potential future debut. Then they appear again with the second batch as Fanny is flung through the air by Robot Flower. Then they appear once more with the third batch buried underground as A Better Name Than That digs for the emeralds. Then they appear once more during the credits of the episode.
In "Don't Dig Straight Down", they appear in three different groups of recommended character crowd scenes for that episode being recommended by Space W. They first appear with the first batch buried underground while iance is digging to escape the lava. Then they appear again with the second batch above ground screaming while being burnt to death by the lava after Cake mentions that everyone is probably dead.
In "The Four is Lava", they appear in two different groups of recommended characters for that episode being recommended by Space W. They first appear with the first batch in the lava as Saw and Dora go to Four to tell him about their team. Then Midnight's Popcorn appears with the second batch slowly sinking into the lava as Four takes the remaining underground members of to the Cake at Stake area.
Battle for BFB[]
In "How Loe Can You Grow?", they appear during the credits of the episode being recommended by DanicalsAtChina.
In "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning", they appear during the credits of the episode being recommended by Emma A.
In "Chapter Complete", they appear during the credits of the episode in both batches being recommended by Emma A.
Trivia[]
- The most recent Cake Pop recommendation as of the time of the BFB 16 debut voting would have been the Cake Pop from BFB 15 meaning that this is the design that likely would have been used if they went up for voting.
- In the same clip where Cary mentions Cake Pop being considered for a spot in the BFB 16 debut voting, Cary also mentions that 30 characters were supposed to be up for debut. This means that, alongside Cake Pop, there are three other past recommended characters that were considered but ultimate scrapped. It is currently unknown which characters those are however.
Gallery[]
Assets[]
Poses[]
Root Beer[]
Root Beer is a recommended character that was originally recommended for IDFB 2 with a chance of getting to join the pool of contestants inside the TLC and potentially become a contestant upon being freed. Root Beer received the most upvotes out of the recommended characters, meaning they would have been sent to the TLC. However, due to IDFB’s indefinite hiatus, the idea was scrapped and the IDFB 2 recommended characters appeared in BFB 2 instead.[3]
Appearance[]
Root Beer is a wide glass beer mug filled with dark brown root beer and with tan frothed liquid on top that is dripping down the mug side.
Changes[]
BFDI 20
- Root Beer uses Bottle's old asset.
- Root Beer is half filled with root beer.
- Root Beer has no froth.
- Root Beer's face is black.
BFB 2
- Root Beer is a wide glass beer mug.
- Root Beer is fully filled with root beer.
- Root Beer has overflowing froth.
- Root Beer's face is white.
Coverage[]
Appearances[]
- Battle for Dream Island
- "Gardening Hero" (recommended)
- "Return of the Hang Glider" (recommended)
- Battle for Dream Island Again
- Battle for BFDI
- "Lick Your Way to Freedom" (recommended)
- "The Four is Lava" (as Red Cream Soda, debatable)
- Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two
- "BFB 31"
Battle for Dream Island[]
In "Gardening Hero", they appear during the second recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by bebgsurg. In that scene they are one of the gaspers, specifically gasping at the reveal that the coming rejoin was gonna be the last rejoin of the season.
In "Return of the Hang Glider", they are seen with all the other recommended characters from season 1 during the panning scene on the bleachers watching the last Cake at Stake of the season, they are grouped with all the other episode 20 recommended characters. They are part of the recommended character "Every Recommended Character" recommended by marioluigi0128 in the previous episode.
Battle for Dream Island Again[]
In "Get in the Van", they appear in the anniversary wheel that starts the episode with all the other season 1 recommended characters.
Battle for BFDI[]
In "Lick Your Way to Freedom", they appear during the recommended characters crowd scene for that episode being recommended by thetgrodz. They are shown when Donut is flung backwards.
Trivia[]
- It's possible that Root Beer reappeared as Red Cream Soda in "The Four is Lava" as they were recommended by the same person and have a very similar appearance, albeit Red Cream Soda being recolored. Additionally, Red Cream Soda's BFDI-asset pose references the appearance of the recommended character crowd from "Lick Your Way to Freedom" which Root Beer was seen amongst.
Gallery[]
Assets[]
References[]
- ↑ Male according to recommender https://www.reddit.com/r/a:t5_3g2ll/comments/50lt49/idfb_1_character_recommendations/
.jpeg){kind=link}
