Pencil's alliance is an alliance that originally consisted of Pencil, Match, Bubble, and Ice Cube (as a temporary substitute). However, Ruby and Book later joined the group with the former being an official member and the latter being an "alternate". In "Get in the Van", the alliance becomes a separate team named FreeSmart.
In "Take the Plunge: Part 2", Pin picked Pencil to join her team instead of Leafy's team to keep Ice Cube, who was on Leafy's team, from joining the alliance. Pencil picked Match and Bubble because of the alliance.
In "Bridge Crossing", when Bubble fell down, Pencil and Match jumped down shortly afterwards.
In "Power of Three", the whole alliance was a team of three. The alliance team gets third place.
In "Don't Lose Your Marbles", the fact that the alliance stayed together for so long is mentioned.
In "Half a Loaf Is Better Than None", the alliance is finally broken by Match's elimination, but she is soon replaced by Ice Cube.
In "The Reveal", Pencil says Ice Cube is not in her alliance right now, because she picked Bubble to pair up with.
In "Reveal Novum", Pencil says that her alliance stays for another day, as Ice Cube is safe.
In "Rescission", Bubble tells Ice Cube that the alliance is too small, and Ice Cube wants "Needy" to join, being slapped shortly afterwards. Ice Cube says she is no longer in the alliance after Bubble considers giving immunity to her. The alliance is over for BFDI.
In "Return of the Hang Glider", the alliance members ask to enter Dream Island together.
In "Get Digging", Ruby joins the alliance after Pencil and Match invite her. Pencil intentionally hesitated because of the other alliance members, Bubble and Ice Cube, but after hearing the two's reasons why they are no longer in the alliance, she accepted it. Later, they talk about reviving Bubble with a bubble blower, but Ruby questions why reviving her is necessary, as Pencil and Match are doing fine even without her presence.
In "Insectophobe's Nightmare 3", the alliance didn't participate in the contest. Before Pencil and Match revive Bubble with the bubble blower, Ruby confesses that she acted weird because she fears that if Bubble is back in the alliance, she will be kicked out. Pencil and Match forgive her, and said she won't, as they will have an alliance of 4 members. After Bubble is revived and rejoins the alliance, she is surprised upon Ruby's presence and kicked her away because she thought that Ruby wasn't in her alliance. Ruby blames Pencil and Match for lying to her, which the two told her that Ruby is also in their alliance now, and asks why Bubble rejected her. Bubble didn't want Ruby to be in the alliance because Golf Ball said that an alliance of more than three members would split up. After Pencil tells her that Golf Ball was wrong, Bubble accepts Ruby. Ice Cube wants to join again, as well as Book, and they were accepted as alternates.
In "Get in the Van", Pencil and Match have Ice Cube and Book kicked out of the Clubhouse of Awesomeness because they are just alternates. Later, however, the alliance becomes a separate team named FreeSmart, which included both the alliance's members and the alternate ones.
In "Getting Teardrop to Talk", Pencil demotes Bubble from Member to "Bember" because she stopped Lightning from zapping Flower. Book and Ice Cube leave Pencil's Alliance and join , because Book thinks being in the alliance is "too unhealthy".
Pencil is eliminated in "Lick Your Way to Freedom", which leaves only Match, Bubble, and Ruby in the alliance.
In "Questions Answered", Bubble is once again demoted to “bemb” by Match.
In "What Do You Think of Roleplay?", Match was eliminated, which leaves only Bubble and Ruby in the alliance.
In "Return of the Rocket Ship", Ice Cube joins Team Ice Cube!, but then leaves and joins the alliance instead. Flower mentions she can't do that but Bubble says to let her think what she wants. As of now, the alliance consists of Bubble, Ruby, and Ice Cube (though unofficially).
- Bubble (formerly)
- Bubble (currently)
- Book (formerly; left alliance and joined )
- It seems like alternate ranking is the lowest ranking before being expelled, as Pencil threatened Book to expel her in "Getting Teardrop to Talk".
- As of "Getting Teardrop to Talk", Book and Ice Cube have left the alliance and created their own team, .
- There is no "Leader" rank, but Pencil was in charge of the alliance before being eliminated. Match seemed to take on this role after Pencil, but as she is now eliminated, the "leader" is unclear. It's possible Ruby has taken on the role, but this is not confirmed.
- Although Pencil was the leader of the alliance before being eliminated, Bubble was the one who originally formed and founded the alliance.
- Everyone in the alliance is female.
- Despite being demoted twice, Bubble does not seem to have lost any privileges.
- Ice Cube seemed to have unofficially joined the alliance in "Return of the Rocket Ship", despite Flower saying that wasn't possible.