Bomby Plush is a recommended character that appeared in "Uprooting Everything" and in "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning". They were recommended by pezzy. They are a plush version of Bomby. It appeared in "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning" where Flower gave it to Woody as a gift.
Bubble Plush is a variation of Bubble that appeared in "Who Stole Donut's Diary?". It is a plushie version of Bubble and was recommended by Fivestuff.
Cursed Leafy is a recommended character recommended by Cameron in "The Game Has Changed". They are a darker green variant of Leafy with large black eyes and is also poorly drawn. This variation of Leafy is based on the first prototype of the Leafy plush which Cary has referred to as "Cursed Leafy" previously.
The Four Plush, first appeared in "B.F.B. = Back From Beginning", where when as to makeover Four in some way, shape, or form, Teardrop ended up crafting up the Four Plush and put it on the table, in front of her, later Flower and Gelatin, pick up the plush and put it back down, to advance to the next themed challenge.
Glow in the Dark Firey Plush
Pin Plush is a recommended character shown in "Fashion For Your Face!". It is a plush version of Pin. It was recommended by Fivestuff.
Stuffed Leafy is a recommended character recommended by SliderCentral in "Fashion For Your Face!" and "The Game Has Changed". It is a variant of Leafy that is stuffed like a plushy and is poorly drawn.
- Some plushies look similar to a character from Yoshi's Island.