Leafy is walking down the "sidewalk", thinking about visiting Goiky's newly opened library with one of her friends, like Firey or Tennis Ball. She then encounters two Fireys, and faints. The two Fireys get worried because of this. Leafy, now back up after a Firey getting dropped on her, wants to know which Firey is real, and conducts some tests.
Leafy knows that the real Firey would scream because of his fear of heights, so she puts the Fireys on a bar. Both scream and one falls down. Leafy is still confused on which one is Firey, because both of them screamed at the same time. Leafy decides on doing another challenge, and the Fireys get angry at this.
Leafy brings the original Coiny with her, saying that the real Firey would know what to do with him. Cary's Firey starts slapping Coiny, and Michael's Firey gets slapped by him. Both argue about who's the real Firey, but Leafy still doesn't know which is the real one.
Leafy brings the Fireys to the Evil Forest, and tells them that the real Firey would know when the Evil version of her would come. Cary's Firey starts to pick up a presence, while Michael's Firey doesn't hear anything at all. Cary's Firey starts falling backwards, and Leafy tells them there was no Evil Leafy. The Fireys are relieved, but then Evil Leafy appears behind them, and the Fireys scream and possibly get eaten.
Leafy compliments them on finding Evil Leafy, but now she's alone, and asks Coiny for help. The Fireys are now at the table, and they said they faked their deaths. Leafy's so happy now that the Fireys are alive, but is still unable to tell which Firey is real. Coiny replies that Michael's Firey is real, and the real Firey calls the fake Firey "loser", but he says that he's honored and falls/faints, and Leafy orders a death penalty for the fake Firey.
At the end, the video announces that the Leafy plush will be available late July 2020, and that they do not condone usage of death penalty, and that the word "loser" referred to the majestic BFB contestant.
Now that Leafy and Firey are in the Goiky Library, Leafy wants to read some books with Firey, but he says that he can't read.
When the animation for the grand opening for the Goiky Library shows up, it doesn't cover all of the screen, as shown in the right, the original setting is still shown.
Fake Firey is extinguished in a pool by Firey and Leafy as a death penalty.
Despite his name, Coiny does not look like a coin in this short.
A theory in the chat is Coiny is portrayed by a magnet.